Güllü's son: 'My sister Tuğyan is the one saying the words, "I'll throw you out the window, will you jump?"'

On September 26, in Yalova's Cinarcik district, Harmanlar Neighborhood, Vali Aki Street on the 5th floor of an apartment building on the enclosed terrace, famous singer Güllü (52), while having fun with her daughter and a friend, fell from the window and lost her life. Regarding Güllü's death, in the investigation conducted by the Yalova Chief Public Prosecutor's Office, Güllü's daughter Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter, who was taken into custody, was arrested on the charge of "premeditated murder of a close relative," while Sultan Nur Ulu was placed under house arrest. Regarding the incident, Güllü's son Tuğberk Yağız Gülter gave a statement at the Yalova Courthouse in the capacity of a witness. Gülter stated that on the day the incident occurred in Yalova, he was in Istanbul. Stating that arguments frequently broke out between his mother and his sister,

Gülter said that this never turned into physical violence. he said thatthe violencedid notend.

Statingthat heand hissisterhad not gotten along sincechildhood, Gülter notedthat theyarguedfrequently. Stating that they wanted to use the house where the incident occurred as a place for condolences, Gülter said, "We needed to enter the house in Çınarcık, but I didn't have the key. My sister had left the house without taking anything. She was in a state of shock at the hospital. The police also pulled the door shut and left after the crime scene investigation. They didn't have the key either. I even called the company that installed this coded door, but when I couldn't reach them, I sent a message on Instagram. Ultimately, since I couldn't reach the people, I thought I could enter through our neighbor Seval aunt's terrace to get into the house. I couldn't notify a locksmith either because this door wasn't a normal door; it was a coded door, and I think they would have had to remove the whole thing." Gülternotedthat heentered the house by breaking the window and then opened the door for those waiting outside.Gülter continued, "Ientered the house by breaking the window and then opened the door for those waiting outside. The police had leftafter the crime scene investigation. They didn't have the key either. I even called the company that installed this coded door, but when I couldn't reach them, I sent a message on Instagram. Ultimately, since I couldn't reach the people, I thought I could enter through our neighbor Seval aunt's terrace to get into the house. I couldn't notify a locksmith either because this door wasn't a normal door; it was a coded door, and I think they would have had to remove the whole thing." I sent a message onInstagram. Ultimately,since I couldnot reach the people, Ithought I could enter through our neighbor Seval aunt's terrace to get into the house.Icouldnot notify a locksmith either because this doorwas not a normal door; it was a coded door, and I think they would have had to remove the whole thing." Ientered the house by breaking the window and then opened the door for those waiting outside," he said.

Noting that he entered the house by breaking the window and then opened the door for those waiting outside,Gülteradded, "Gülter"Gülter stated that things like money or gold were not kept in his mother's safe. Gülter noted that the safe contained his grandmother's cut hair, his mother's bank passbooks, song lyrics written by his mother, and documents regarding her copyrights, all kept in a green backpack.

Addressing the audio recordings from the moment of the incident, Gülter spoke as follows: "I listened to the audio recordings from after entering Tuğyan's room on the internet. I think the person saying 'Let's see' there is my mother,

but I am not entirely sure. Because I listened to it once a long time ago. It was shortly after the incident. I just assumed it was my mother and moved on. I haven't listened to it again recently, and I haven't analyzed it at length. The words, 'Is everyone ready? What is that? Wow, it's wonderful, look. Look, look at those maniacs. Come, come. Girl, come here. Girl, come. Bitch,' belong to my mother. Even though I cannot hear some of the sounds clearly, what my mother said is clear. My sister Tuğyan is the one saying the words, 'I'll throw you out the window, will you jump?'"there are words, but because of themusic and the sound of playing, I cannot hear them clearly.The voice you hear as 'Leave me alone' also belongs to my mother. The voice saying 'I don't know how to play' belongs to Sultan. My sister Tuğyan is the one saying the words 'I'll throw you out the window, will you jump?' that I heard in the video.Also, in the audio recording I listened to,the words I heard as 'Is there a need?' or 'Is there a butterfly?'are said by my sister. The phraseI understood as 'Come here'is also said by my sister. For the words 'See you' at the end of the video,Isometimes think it sounds like my mother's voice, and other times like Tuğyan's voice. I cannot say anything definitive about that.I have stated the parts of the audio recordingthat I listened to and definitively thoughtbelongedto mymother.But I cannot clearly state who the 'See you' sentence at the very end belongs to.Icannot specify who that sentencebelongs to."

"There isno reason for her to go to that narrowopen window"Gülter explained

that his mother was afraid of windowsand stayed away from them unlessnecessary.Noting that there could only be 3 reasons for his mother to be near the window that daydespite it being open,Gülter said,"The first of these could be to close theopen window. Because, as I said,she was afraid of openwindows; she might have wanted to close it. The 2nd reason might be, assheactually said, a small insect like a butterflymight have been there.The third reason could besomething else."there was something, it to avoid killing her, take her from the windowand might have wanted to throw her.

The 3rd reason is that someone somehow took her to the windowandmade her fall. Because my mother would definitely never go to that narrowwindow area for no reason,if she wanted to play, she would want to go to a widearea. My sister constantly smokes in the room.That's why the window is always open.Since my mother didn't like the smell of cigarettes,she would usually say things to my sister like, 'You've made the roomsmell like smoke again, open the window.'Tuğyan's bed in Tuğyan's room was actuallyparallel to the window a weekago. Then they placed the bed perpendicular to the window. Just like it was at the moment of the incident.My guess is that my mother thought my sister sleeps restlessly and wanted the bed to be changed that way. My mother wouldn't allow the bed to be that way," he stated.To the questionofwhether she could kill your mother, the answer:"She can do anything for Kervan."

Gülter stated that his mother hated his sister's boyfriend Kervan,saying, "There were a few reasons.The first reason is Tuğyan. Tuğyan would erase everyone around her for the man in her life.

She would stand against everyone.I remembera period, though I don't remember the exact date,when my sisterwas pregnant with twins from Kervan....... ............ I heard from my mother that she was pregnant with thechild. I don't know if my sister miscarriedthebabyorhad it aborted at the hospital, but I heard about the pregnancyprocess from my mother in thisway. My sister loved Kervan. During my sister's suicide attempt, she went to the window and said to my mother, 'You killed me, you disgraced me.' My sisterwould cut off everyone around her for the man in her life," he said. Gülter, when asked, "Could your sister Tuğyan kill your mother for Kervan?" replied, "I don't want to bear the sin, but she could kill for Kervan. Because my sister is a weak-charactered person when it comes to relationships. She could do anything for Kervan. She was like that in her previous relationships, too," he said.Providing information about what his sister told him regarding the events of the day of the incident, Gülternoted the following:"When I asked Tuğyan after this incident whether she saw my mother falling, she told me that she saw her foot or a part of her dress while my mother was falling."

dayshe said. She toldme this in the first weeks after the incident occurred.She said.I asked her if she saw my motherfalling.She toldme, 'Yağız, I don't remember. I saw either her dress or her foot.'I did not ask Tuğyan for the details of the incident.I did not ask details such as how my mother got to the window, where Sultan was, or where Tuğyan was standing, or what happened on the day of the incident.I only asked if she saw my motherfalling.I also asked, 'Isn't the last song that played the song my mother used to come down from the stage to?'She said, 'Yes, Malkata.'I had not asked Tuğyan how theyplayedMalkata or who requested it.However, 2-3 days ago, I asked Çi ğdem sister questions to clear up my doubts, such as 'Did my sister listen to this Malkata on other days, why did they play Malkata at the moment of the incident?'Çiğdem also told me that my sister listened to this song from time to time.""My sister is someone who tells many lies; 9 out of 10 thingsshe says are lies."Gülter stated that Sultan Nur Uluused drugs, and therefore a hair samplewas taken.The investigation continues.

The court process is ongoing.The defense lawyers requested a new expert report.

The judge rejected the request.The trial was adjourned to a later date.The family members were present in the courtroom.The atmosphere was tense.The prosecutor demanded a life sentence.The final verdict is expected soon.noted that he was afraid to give a statement. Gülter, when askedwhether his sisterused drugs or not,replied, "Let me alsostate this, I know clearly from my mother that Tuğyan hasahistory of drug use. I also know that my mother tried very hardto get herto quit.

According to her own statement, Tuğyanclaims shequit these drugs 5-7 years ago andhas not used themsince.However, Imust also say this. My sisteris someone who liesa lot; 9 out of every 10 things she says are lies.She is a person who lies a lot," he said. "There is nothing she wouldn't do for her relationship."

Explaining thathis suspicionsthat the incidentcould be a murder

were growing, Gülter said, "Mysuspicions wereforming and then fading. Ithought that my sisteror Sultan would do sucha thing, IthoughtaboutI didn't believe it. Because when I watched the videosmy sister was screamingvery loudly; my sister was very upset after the incident, she was constantlyscreaming. Seeing her grief, it didn't cross mymindthat she could do such a thing. However, as I mentioned above, my sister has a personality prone to lying, she loves her own interests very much, and there is nothing she wouldn't do forher ownbenefit."Stating that his sister occasionally argued with their mother because of Kervan, he

spoke as follows:"She has a nervous, aggressive, and quarrelsome nature. Now, when Ithink about

all the events and the confession statement given by Sultan, I cannotfathom it; I want to believe that my sisterwould not do such a thing. I want to believe that these are nottrue.If she did it, I am a complainant.If my mother died due to a murder, I am a complainantagainst everyone who did it, thought about it, or was involved in the incident.If such a thing did not happen, I hope she proves it. If such athingdid happen,may they rot in prison for the rest of their lives. Above all else,I want justice.Iama complainant.I am a complainant.If such a thing is not true, I hope she proves it. If such athing is true, may they stay in prison until the end of their lives.Above all else, if theycome out, they will face me. I want the truthtocomeoutinto thelight."

"Ihope she didn't do such a thing"

Explainingthat Tuğyan had not previously told him anything about wanting to kill their mother,Gülter stated that he had no knowledgeof the factsof the incident, saying, "Tuğyandid not tell meafter the incidentthat she pushed my mother.We didn't even talk about such a thing. I don't even know if I would ask such a question if I go to visit her in prison on Thursday.I am afraid of the answer I might receive; I hope she didn't do such athing. I have no informationabout their escape plans.In fact, when the audio recording regarding the escapeleakedto the media,I messaged Tuğyan on WhatsApp,'I justfound out,thisisveryserious,' Isaid.What is this talk about Georgia and France, whyare you making noise, where are you planning torunaway to, why?' I wrote, but she didn't write anything back to me, then I called her, I was angry, and she told methat there was no such escape planand that the audio recordings had been cut andeditedand leaked that way,so I said,if it's not true, then you provide the original.In this same conversation, I told her that she would have to answer to me for the messages she sent to Bircan regarding my mother. She didn't give me any answer," he said.

Gülter handed over his phone to the prosecutor'soffice for examinationof his own freewill.