The age of no exit! Poverty is no longer a state, but a trap

Activist Erkan Erdem wrote about poverty and its effects: "This trap is not unique to Turkey. From the ghettos of Brazil to the slums of India, from the Black neighborhoods in America to lives in the shadows of Istanbul's skyscrapers, this is now a global geometry of collapse"...

12punto

Some forms of poverty are temporary. You become unemployed, you get back on your feet. You get into debt, you somehow recover. But there is another type of poverty that has no exit, one that is chilling even by name: The poverty trap.

This trap is set not only for your pocket; it is set for your mind, your dreams, and even the future of your children. That is why the issue is not just that "you have no money." The issue is the belief that there is no exit door. And even more terrifyingly, sometimes there really is no exit.

NOT POVERTY, BUT A SYSTEM THAT TURNS INTO A TRAP

Poverty is no longer an individual situation; it is a form of fate engineering that operates systematically.

If you don't have an education, you can't get a decent job. Because you can't get a decent job, your income is low. If your income is low, you cannot send your child to private tutoring or a private school. They, too, are dragged into a cycle "destined for failure" just like you.

In short: poverty neither starts with you, nor does it end with you.

This trap is not unique to Turkey. From the ghettos of Brazil to the slums of India, from the Black neighborhoods in America to lives in the shadows of Istanbul's skyscrapers, this is now a global geometry of collapse.

TRAPS ARE MULTIPLYING: NO LONGER SINGULAR, BUT PLURAL

Today, the poverty trap is no longer just a matter of "the poor in the village" or "the unemployed laborer."

We are talking about multi-layered traps that operate more subtly and insidiously.

THE EDUCATION TRAP

The gap between public schools and private schools is not just about the building; it is also a difference in self-confidence, language, and future prospects.

If your child's classmates are "different," that child grows up thinking they are "lacking."

THE HEALTH TRAP

Chronic illness, being unable to go to work, and not being able to afford medication solidify poverty.

THE GEOGRAPHIC TRAP

If there is no transportation, no internet, there are no people.

This means "there is no life." Especially if you were born in that village, if you grew up in that neighborhood, you are born into a trap.

THE INSTITUTIONAL TRAP

In the state, you get a job "if you have connections." If not, no exam is enough to guarantee your justice.

And the state, while it should be the insurance of social justice, acts today only like a charitable holding company.

It gives alms, not rights. It rules through favors.

It has reduced the poor from citizens with rights to consumers who "say thank you" in line.

WHITE-COLLAR WORKERS: NOW INSIDE THE TRAP

White-collar workers were once the "saved class." They had diplomas, offices, and early reservations.

But now there is an office, but no hope.

The June 2025 report by the Istanbul Planning Agency hits us in the face with the truth:

76% of white-collar workers in Istanbul cannot make ends meet or save money.

While 43% cannot save anything at all, nearly 10% cannot even cover their basic needs.

The average rent has exceeded 20 thousand TL. White-collar workers spend 60% of their average salary just on housing.

While the OECD average for the share of household income allocated to food is 12%, this rate has risen to 35% in Turkey.

This new picture has revealed a new type of trap: Status-based poverty.

Meaning: You are a white-collar worker, but you exist not through your standard of living, but through your business card.

The poverty trap for white-collar workers is now three-layered:

1. Financial Trap: You have an income, but it is not enough. You go into debt. You are condemned to a chain of rent, credit cards, and installments.

2. Sociological Trap: While you think you are "successful," you are actually systematically melting away.

3. Cultural Trap: You cannot dream of anything new because every dream means a "burden": Buying a house is a burden, having a child is a burden, traveling is impossible.

And these traps are even more dire because:

The white-collar worker cannot admit they are poor.

The fear of losing status is the quietest, deepest pit of the trap.

White-collar workers are no longer just struggling to pay their rent; they are forced to cut back on their relationship with life.

Cinema, theater, a dinner out... These activities, which were once ordinary, now require serious planning.

Vacations turn into dreams, books into PDFs, and birthday gifts into postponements.

Salaries dictate not just the necessity of making a living, but the necessity of simplifying life.

MULTIPLE TRAUMA SYNDROME: THE POVERTY OF TODAY

This is no longer just about the missing money in your pocket.

Poverty is now an erosion of identity, a mental trap.

Think about it:

A baby born in a poor neighborhood today; if they attend a public school, if they are in a medicine line when they are sick, if they have never seen a vacation...

That child is not just poor, they were born condemned to poverty.

And worse, the child of the white-collar worker is now approaching this same condemnation.

WHAT SHOULD BE DONE? HOW CAN HOPE BE REBUILT?

1. The solution to these traps is not aid packages, but fair systems.

2. The quality of education should not depend on the income of the neighborhood. Public schools must cease to be the "forced choice of the poor." Schools should turn into centers of social justice.

3. Basic health services must be free and equal. This is the measure of humanity, not wealth.

4. If teachers and engineers cannot rent a house in Istanbul, this is not a housing crisis; it is a civilization crisis.

5. Poverty will not end until institutions are established where merit, not nepotism, speaks.

6. We must develop policies not only for the poor but also for those who are becoming impoverished.

Because the fall of this class is the loss of the entire society.

7. The white-collar worker is contracted, insecure, and left alone. If they don't have a union, they don't have a voice.

That is why new-generation union organizations are the clearest step to breaking this trap.

FINAL WORD: WHERE IS THE KEY TO OPEN THE TRAPS?

Poverty is no longer defined by hunger; it is defined by hopelessness.

What we call a trap cannot feed not only the child's stomach but also their dreams.

Therefore:

Where capitalism says "let the race begin," if some still have to run barefoot, it means there is a serious problem.

The issue is to establish a fair order where everyone starts from the same line with equal shoes.

And yes, I am writing from inside these traps.

Because sometimes writing is also a way of resisting.