Treasury and Finance Minister Mehmet Şimşek made evaluations regarding current issues on the Başkent Kulisi program broadcast on Kanal 7. Providing explanations on many topics ranging from fund liquidation to allegations of capital flight abroad, and from meetings to be held with international investors to studies on retirement pensions, Şimşek shared the details of the process.
"WE ARE MOVING QUITE FAST COMPARED TO SIMILAR SITUATIONS IN THE WORLD"
Stating that the fund liquidation process is progressing rapidly when compared to international examples, Şimşek said that in a similar incident that occurred in the USA in 2008, the first payment was made in 2011 and payments are still ongoing.
Expressing that the work in Turkey is progressing ahead of the planned schedule, Şimşek stated that the principles of transparency, justice, and not using public resources were adopted in the liquidation process and spoke as follows:
"We are moving quite fast compared to similar situations in the world. The most famous case in this regard is the case in America. It emerged in 2008, the first payment was made in 2011. Payments are still ongoing. Returning to Turkey, this liquidation process is going as planned, and even better than we planned in terms of speed. We introduced some principles. Transparency, justice, and not using public money in payments."
"WE EVEN PAID THE ACCRUED INTEREST EARNED DURING THE LIQUIDATION PROCESS"
Şimşek announced that 131 funds were included in the scope of liquidation on September 17 and that there were approximately 456 thousand customers in these funds. Stating that the funds in good standing were subjected to ordinary liquidation procedures, Şimşek said that the ordinary liquidation of 97 funds has been completed, and the transactions for 37 people in 3 closed funds have not yet been concluded.
Stating that 93 billion liras were paid to 415,955 people in 25 funds under extraordinary liquidation, Şimşek noted that the total payment amount reached 167 billion liras.
Şimşek made the following statements regarding the liquidation efforts:
"On September 17, we included 131 funds in the scope of liquidation. There were around 456 thousand customers. Those of these funds that were not impaired were subjected to the normal liquidation process. 4 companies were liquidated normally. 3 companies were liquidated extraordinarily. 97 of the 131 funds were liquidated normally. There are only 3 closed funds with 37 people whose liquidation has not yet been carried out. We even paid the accrued interest earned during the liquidation process. This process is complete.
As for the extraordinary liquidation, 93 billion liras were paid to 415,955 people from 25 funds here. To date, a total of 167 billion TL has been paid to 444,981 people. 371,021 of the 456 thousand people have exited the system. These 371 thousand people have received their receivables."
"WE MAKE PAYMENTS AS CASH IS GENERATED"
Stating that the payments made in the fund liquidation were not covered by public resources, Şimşek reported that the transactions were carried out through İş Bankası and Ziraat Bankası, and that the decisions regarding the liquidation were taken by the Capital Markets Board (SPK).
Stating that there is an accumulation of 35.6 billion liras in the refund and recovery account created by the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (TMSF), Şimşek stated that the majority of this resource was transferred to the relevant funds and paid to investors.
Regarding the operation of the payment process, Şimşek made the following explanation:
"Payments are quite fast and quite transparent. İş Bankası and Ziraat Bankası are carrying out the liquidation. The SPK makes the decisions. We are not using public resources. These are the funds' own resources. There has been an accumulation of 35.6 billion TL in the refund and recovery account created by the TMSF. Most of this was transferred to these funds and paid out. We make payments as cash is generated."
"WE STARTED PAYMENTS WITH THE SMALLEST SHAREHOLDERS"
Stating that the assets within the scope of liquidation are converted into cash and transferred to investors, Şimşek said that the payment transactions were carried out by taking market conditions into account.
Noting that payments will continue as new resources accumulate in the TMSF's refund and recovery accounts, Şimşek stated that small shareholders were prioritized and that payments of 1 million liras and above would also be made if resources are generated.
Şimşek made the following statements regarding the payment method:
"Two days before the liquidation, the assets are converted into cash at the market rate, and that money is transferred to Ziraat and İş Bankası and paid to the rights holders. As long as there is accumulation in the TMSF's refund and recovery accounts, these payments will be made. The process worked very well in ordinary liquidations. Payments will be prioritized as resources are generated. We started payments with the smallest shareholders. As resources are generated, payments of 1 million TL and above will be made."
"THE SPK HAS ALSO BEEN EXAMINING THE SHARES OF THESE FUNDS THAT HAVE BEEN EXPLOITED AND MANIPULATED IN RECENT YEARS"
Touching upon the allegations of manipulation in shares linked to the funds, Şimşek stated that the SPK continues its examinations regarding the shares in question.
Announcing that 25 inspectors from the Ministry of Finance have been assigned to the SPK to accelerate the examinations, Şimşek said that the goal is to complete the work by the end of the month.
Stating that after the examinations, criminal complaints will be filed against those determined to have engaged in market-disrupting transactions and that unfair gains will be identified, Şimşek spoke as follows:
"The SPK has also been examining the shares of these funds that have been exploited and manipulated in recent years. 25 inspectors were transferred from the Ministry of Finance to the SPK. These examinations will be completed by the end of the month. At the end of the examinations, criminal complaints will be filed against those who engaged in market-disrupting actions, and unfair gains will be identified."
"THESE ARGUMENTS WILL BE PROVEN WRONG"
Evaluating the effects of the fund liquidation process on the Turkish economy, Şimşek said that the developments coincided with the decline in world stock markets.
Stating that the loss of wealth is in the first place in the effect of the fund issue on the economy, Şimşek objected to the assessments that the entire decline in the stock market was caused by fund developments.
In his statement on the subject, Şimşek made the following remarks:
"The primary channel of impact of the fund issue on the Turkish economy is the erosion of wealth. The fund issue and the decline in world stock markets coincided. They point to this by saying there is a decline in the stock market. But the stock market is rising. These arguments will be proven wrong."
"THE FUND ISSUE AND REGIONAL NEGATIVITIES CAME ONE AFTER ANOTHER"
Evaluating the loss of value in Borsa Istanbul together with developments in international markets, Şimşek stated that the average decline in the stock markets of developing countries was 8 percent, while the decline in Turkey was 9 percent. He stated that the impact of the fund issue on this decline was at the level of 1 percent.
Stating that the Brazilian stock market fell by 7 percent, and the Malaysian, Chilean, and Philippine stock markets fell by 6 percent, Şimşek said that developments in global markets also affected Turkey.
Şimşek made the following statements in his evaluation:
"The market value of all companies in the stock market is 409 billion dollars. It was 300 billion dollars in November. Yes, there is a loss of value. But the average decline in the stock markets of all developing countries in the same period is 8 percent, and the stock market in Turkey fell by 9 percent. The effect of the fund on this decline is 1 percent. The Brazilian stock market fell by 7 percent, and the Malaysian, Chilean, and Philippine stock markets fell by 6 percent. Since September 16, expectations that the US, Japan, and EU Central Banks would raise interest rates have deteriorated. 10-year bond yields reached their highest level in the last 25 years. It was discussed that the war could restart or even that a nuclear war could break out. Oil rose from 90 dollars to 120 dollars during that period. The fund issue and regional negativities came one after another.
Those who had savings in the money market or funds and had money left over may have had trouble accessing liquidity. But with the liquidation, this incident was resolved. 445 thousand out of 456 thousand people received payments. Those who could not receive payments are those whose accounts were blocked. Banks have only 1.3 billion shares in these funds. 2 out of 100 thousand. It is out of the question for this crisis to spread to the banking sector. The real sector's risk to the fund crisis is 116 billion TL. We looked at companies experiencing high risk. Their impact is 2 out of 10 thousand."
"THE MONEY COMING OUT OF THE FUND IS PAID IN TL, SO THERE WAS NO DOLLARIZATION EITHER"
Evaluating the effect of the fund liquidation process on the foreign exchange market, Şimşek said that investor payments were made in Turkish Lira and that there was no significant increase in dollarization.
Stating that Central Bank reserves were at the level of 161 billion dollars in the latest announcement, Şimşek stated that there was a decrease of approximately 16 billion dollars compared to September 16, and that 42 percent of this decline was due to the drop in gold prices.
In his statement on the subject, Şimşek made the following remarks:
"When such an incident occurs in Turkey, there would be a rise in the exchange rate. There is no significant increase in dollarization. The money coming out of the fund is paid in TL. So there was no dollarization either. Central Bank reserves were last announced as 161 billion dollars. It has fallen by roughly 16 billion dollars compared to September 16. 42 percent of this fell due to the drop in gold. This has nothing to do with the fund crisis.
We imposed taxes on all funds, regardless of whether they were domestic or foreign. Due to these developments, there are foreign funds that sold their shares and took their savings out. We have been saying for a long time that we do not want carry trade. We imposed taxes. The Central Bank cut interest rates and carry trade became less attractive."
"MASAK EXAMINED THE 401 BILLION TL ALLEGATION AND PROVED THAT IT WAS NOT TRUE"
Addressing the allegations regarding the 401 billion lira money movement linked to the funds, Şimşek stated that the entire amount in question was not money that investors took out of the system.
Stating that 306 billion liras consisted of intra-fund movements and the remaining 95 billion liras were taken under investigation by the prosecutor's office, Şimşek said that the transactions were in the records of the Central Registry Agency (MKK) and that MASAK (Financial Crimes Investigation Board) also conducted an investigation on the subject.
Şimşek made the following statement regarding the allegations:
"There is no exit of 306 billion TL of the 401 billion TL to individuals, these are intra-fund movements. The 95 billion TL portion was also taken under investigation by the prosecutor's office. Everything is on record. All data is in the Central Registry Agency. MASAK is involved. MASAK examined the 401 billion TL allegation and proved that it was not true. The President's stance is clear. Our prosecutors are conducting the necessary investigations, assets are being seized. The SPK has put all transactions in this period under the microscope and has taken action against many people and filed criminal complaints."
"We examined the allegations of capital flight abroad, there is no such exit"
Stating that the allegations that a large amount of money was taken abroad after the fund developments were also investigated, Şimşek said that the examinations were carried out through SWIFT, crypto assets, and electronic payment institutions.
Stating that SWIFT transactions between September 1-16 were examined, Şimşek stated that the capital outflows of 14.7 billion dollars and 7 billion Euros were related to imports. Stating that the allegation that 8 billion dollars were taken out through crypto assets was also investigated, Şimşek also shared the results of the examinations regarding the transactions of electronic payment institutions.
In his statement, Şimşek made the following remarks:
"We examined the allegations of capital flight abroad, there is no such exit. Money can go abroad through 3 channels. Swift, crypto, and electronic payment institutions. We did a study with all 3. All outflows between September 1-16 are related to foreign trade. We looked at the first 16 days of the first 9 months of this year before the fund issue started. 14.7 billion dollars and 7 billion Euros via Swift, and all of it is related to imports. There is no difference between the payments in September.
We examined the allegation that 8 billion dollars in crypto were smuggled. The crypto asset ratio in Turkey is already 4 billion dollars. We looked at the whole year.
We also examined payment institutions. On average, 8 billion TL, or 200 million dollars, went out in the first 15 days of each month. As a result of the investigation conducted by MASAK, the amount of money that went out through other means is not even 200 million dollars."
"WE WILL NOT LEAVE THE SITUATION IN ISTANBUL TO THE INITIATIVE OF OTHERS"
Evaluating the statement of international index provider MSCI regarding Turkey, Şimşek said that the institution's statement regarding the references it takes into account in fund investments was perceived negatively by the public.
Stating that MSCI gave Turkey time until June, Şimşek reported that work for permanent regulations in the fund market continues, the fund guide was published at the end of August, and the draft for the new regulation is largely completed.
Şimşek made the following statements regarding the ongoing work:
"MSCI is a global index provider. MSCI uses some references in fund investments. What percentage of this money do you put into the bonds of developing countries? This provider made a statement and gave us time. This statement was perceived negatively. Actually, it was an extremely reasonable and constructive statement. It gave us a long time until June.
We assigned our Deputy Minister. He will do what needs to be done in this area. We published the fund guide at the end of August. Now there is a permanent reform study. The draft is largely completed and will be submitted to Parliament. We will focus on system construction during this period. We will not leave the situation in Istanbul to the initiative of others."
"PENALTIES FOR MANIPULATIONS MADE THROUGH FUNDS WILL BE INCLUDED IN THE SCOPE OF ORGANIZED CRIME"
Announcing that technological studies to detect manipulative transactions in the fund market are also continuing, Şimşek reported that an algorithm is being developed in cooperation with TÜBİTAK.
Stating that they aim to detect people who engage in market-disrupting transactions using artificial intelligence, Şimşek said that penalties for manipulations will be increased under the new law.
Şimşek made the following statements regarding the planned regulation:
"We are working to create an algorithm in cooperation with TÜBİTAK to detect those who engage in market-disrupting transactions with artificial intelligence. With the new law, penalties for manipulations made through funds will be included in the scope of organized crime and increased."
"WE WILL COME TOGETHER WITH GLOBAL INVESTORS WHO ARE WORRIED ABOUT THIS ISSUE"
Stating that meetings will be held to address the concerns of international investors regarding the fund market, Şimşek said that he will attend the G20 summit to be held in mid-December.
Announcing that he will go to New York after the summit to meet with MSCI senior management, Şimşek stated that he will also come together with global investors to make evaluations on the subject.
Şimşek made the following explanation regarding the meetings and the reform calendar:
"The G20 summit will be attended in mid-December. I will go to New York and talk to MSCI senior management. We will come together with global investors who are worried about this issue and enter into a dialogue. By mid-December, the permanent reform will have taken shape."
"DIFFERENTIATING THE PAYMENT TO BE MADE ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF PREMIUM DAYS PAID WILL TOUCH ALL RETIREES"
In the program, Şimşek also provided information about the improvement studies planned for retirees. Stating that the decrease in earthquake expenditures, the end of the sliding-scale system, and the results obtained in the fight against informality will create resources in the budget, Şimşek said that these resources will be evaluated in the regulation for retirees.
Stating that the study will be completed in December and will cover all retirees, Şimşek stated that it is planned to make different payments according to the number of premium days and made the following explanation:
"There is a decrease in earthquake expenditures, the sliding-scale system is ending because we assume the war will end next year, there is room there, we have achieved success in the fight against informality, there is room there. We will make an improvement for our retirees by using these three areas. It will be completed in December. First of all, it will be inclusive. Differentiating the payment to be made according to the number of premium days paid will touch all retirees, it will touch some more."
News Source: 12punto