A meeting like the declaration of a “Second Republic”!..
Let us present a selection of what Beşir Atalay, who played a leading role as Minister of Interior and Deputy Prime Minister during the first PKK opening process, said at that time.
“The resolution process we are going through is not a give-and-take process... The process we are going through is by no means a process in which we are making concessions. This is a process in which it is realized that violence is not a method, violence is abandoned, and ideas and politics declare sovereignty,” he said, and added the following:
“With this process, our Republic will become even stronger, the roots of our Republic plane tree will reach much deeper, and its branches and leaves will reach much higher.”
He defended the “bill on the termination of terrorism and the strengthening of social integration,” which was brought to the Parliament's agenda in a rush upon the order of the terrorist leader in Imralı, as follows:
- “Hopefully, by bringing the resolution process to success, we will leave this burning issue behind as a country and a nation. We will spend the energy of our country and our people for a Turkey that is shown as an example in its region and in the world. The resolution process is built upon our country's eleven-year accumulation of democratization and normalization. This process is a continuation of the paradigm shift signaled by our Prime Minister's speech in Diyarbakır in 2005 and the National Unity and Brotherhood Project initiated as a state policy in 2009.”
- “The goal of this process is the laying down of arms, the end of violence, and the ensuring of returns home. It has no other goal... There is no third person, no third country, no outside delegation here. For the first time, Turkey is conducting it itself. That is why some are uncomfortable.”
- “We are negotiating directly ourselves, this is our method. We have not involved an international mechanism in these efforts, and we will not.”
While noting that “families of martyrs understand them very well and support them” during that process, Beşir Atalay also used the expressions: “They say, 'May no more martyrs come to other families.' Believe me, there is huge support. People have pinned their hopes on this resolution process for a peaceful Turkey, a Turkey lived in brotherhood.”
Think about the speeches in the current opening process; aren't they so much the same?
IT HAD BEEN PUT ON THE BACK BURNER, AFTER ALL
While all of Turkey is rightly focused on the fund robbery; the new PKK opening, as Erdoğan emphasized while returning from Baku, continues in a “festina lente,” meaning “careful” but “rapid” manner.
Until today, we have always tried to explain, based on the challenges of the terrorist leader-PKK-DEM front, that the process is not just about “laying down arms,” and that there are “give-and-take” bargains taking place that will lead to the terrorists becoming partners in the state.
Finally, the state front has also slowly begun to give signs of this bitter reality. How, you ask?
One day before the 88th anniversary of the death of the founder of the Republic, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the Middle East Research Center (ORSAM) and Oxford University organized a meeting titled “The Search for a New Regional Social Contract in the Middle East” in the middle of Ankara, the Capital of the Republic.
The opening speech of this event was made by TBMM Speaker Numan Kurtulmuş, who established an illegal commission in Parliament for the PKK. What did he say? Here are the main points:
- “We have started a process that we can call the Turkey model... The issue is not just a process consisting of laying down arms or just the disarmament and self-dissolution of an organization. The issue is to pave the way for the peoples that imperialists have scattered in our region for over a century to be reassembled, gathered, and to be together in unity.”
- “A terror-free Turkey is not a project that has come to the agenda of Turkish politics or Turkish public opinion as a project cooked in the capitals of other countries... A process entirely stemming from our own dynamics has been managed and continues to be managed. The Turkey model, with this feature, is an entirely national model.”
- “It should not be forgotten that the fate of the Turk, the Kurd, the Arab, the Sunni, the Shia, the Muslim, the non-Muslim; everyone living in this region is common. If we are talking about a common social contract, a common future of peace, we have to understand that our fates are common, just like our past, and act accordingly.”
- “This door is actually the door that opens to the unity of the Middle Eastern peoples. This door is a door opened to establish a new order in the Middle East. I hope that we will benefit from this door and that we will never allow any imperialist element to enter through this door again.”
- “At the beginning of such an important period, we truly see this effort we have put forward as the Turkey model as the guarantee of the future of the region and Turkey. We consider it the greatest project of the second century of our Republic.”
- “The main thing we are trying to do is to ensure reassembly and gathering in our region. It is to bring our scattered pieces, the peoples of the region who have been pulverized, together again under the umbrella of unity, solidarity, and brotherhood. We set out with this great claim, with this great will, and we have made great progress. No matter what they do, we will definitely, absolutely succeed, and our regional peoples will continue to live in prosperity and peace until doomsday.”
Before moving on to the next speakers, let's underline a few things.
- By saying, “This project is not a project cooked in the capitals of other countries,” is Kurtulmuş not admitting that the previous ones were not “local-national” and “state projects”? Which, in every way, shows that the new opening is a continuation/repetition of the old ones. Hadn't Erdoğan already said, “We put it on the back burner”? It is obvious that it has been taken off the back burner and served with new actors!..
- Regarding the project being “the door that opens to the unity of the Middle Eastern peoples,” let us suffice by recalling these words of Trump's colonial governor Tom Barrack regarding the “Ottoman ummah system”: “A new era is being witnessed in the Middle East and the New East. Turkey has never fully received the value and importance it deserves as a major regional actor... I think Turkey could be the center point of all this, as you see in Syria. A large part of what is happening in Syria is happening thanks to Turkey and its leadership. The millet system in the Ottoman Empire allowed different groups to maintain their existence in the central system for hundreds of years. There is a need for a new dialogue for current generations. This dialogue is not war.”
- As for the opening being “the greatest project of the second century of our Republic”; doesn't it resemble a polite version of the “second republic” rhetoric?
THE “KURDISH ISSUE” ACCORDING TO THE MİT CHIEF
The other important speaker of the meeting was the Head of MİT, İbrahim Kalın, who is the “state mind” of both the previous opening processes and this new one.
First of all; even though Erdoğan said as recently as 2021, “There is no Kurdish problem in Turkey, we have long solved, overcome, and finished this business,” he argued that “at the root of the Kurdish issue lies the perception of exclusion, inequality, and loss of rights experienced by a segment of society,” and said that “the solution must also include the elimination of these problems.”
Anything else?
- He explained that “laying down arms would not be enough in the solution of the Kurdish issue,” and that for a permanent result to be reached, “democratic rights, identity, social memory, and cultural differences must be addressed,” and that “new legal regulations must be implemented” for these.
- Stating that there is some resistance and anxiety in the leadership cadre of the PKK in the form of “What will happen to us?”, that he understands those anxieties, and that they are talking and trying to overcome them, he announced that “additional legal regulations will be prepared for the return of PKK members to Turkey” and that “new legal steps will be taken that will also cover PKK members who are outside the scope of the current regulation.”
- He also reported that “the Kurdish issue has a regional dimension that exceeds Turkey's borders; and that social integration is also important in Syria, Iraq, and Iran.”
In short; the MİT Chief gave the message that they will “continue to pedal” the opening bicycle “no matter what”!..
THE SENIOR FELLOW OF CHATHAM HOUSE
Let us come to Galip Dalay, who is the representative of Oxford University, one of the organizers of the event in question, and who enabled İbrahim Kalın to make these statements with his questions.
Dalay has another hat; he is one of the senior researchers at the famous British Chatham House, which was founded in 1920 and whose first directors were two names from the team that prepared the Treaty of Sèvres.
After the adoption of the framework law regarding the PKK, he wrote the following in the US-based TIME in September, criticizing Turkey's establishment in the 20th century with a nation-state understanding:
“Today, Turkey needs a new nation-state understanding that encompasses different identity groups and a new idea of a strong state built on a broader social legitimacy... Turkey's real test is to build an inclusive national identity that recognizes different identity groups without losing the common bond that connects them to each other. The task of the ongoing Kurdish peace process and the Kurdish politics that will follow it will be exactly to achieve this: an understanding of national identity that is broad and inclusive enough to accommodate Kurdish identity and demands.”
Let us note that Galip Dalay also worked at the SETA Foundation, which is close to the government, during the previous opening processes and advocated views similar to today's.
IF ATATÜRK'S GREATEST WORK IS PROTECTED LIKE THIS
The day after these were discussed in the middle of Ankara was November 10.
In his message, MİT Chief İbrahim Kalın said; “Protecting the gains of our Republic, strengthening our national unity and solidarity, and preserving the independence and security of our country under all conditions is a requirement of the trust we have inherited from the past.” MHP Leader Devlet Bahçeli, who initiated the opening, also emphasized that Atatürk drew attention to the “eternity of his work” with the words, “My greatest work is the Republic” and “The Republic of Turkey will remain forever.”
Should you laugh or cry?!