An employee who had worked at the same workplace for 19 years requested to take additional unpaid leave following a 90-day unpaid leave period. However, the employee did not return to work despite the employer rejecting the request and notifying them both verbally and in writing that they were required to start work on the specified date. Absenteeism reports were filed against the worker, who failed to show up for 10 days. Consequently, the employer terminated the employment contract for just cause and dismissed the worker without severance pay.
WORKER FILED A LAWSUIT FOR SEVERANCE AND OTHER CLAIMS
Following their dismissal, the employee applied to the Labor Court, requesting payment for severance and notice pay, as well as annual paid leave, overtime, national and public holiday pay, weekly rest pay, travel and meal allowances, and the minimum living allowance.
The employer argued that the dismissal was based on just cause, stating that the plaintiff did not come to work for 10 days after their unpaid leave period ended. The employer requested the dismissal of the case.
LOCAL COURT RULED IN FAVOR OF THE WORKER
The Labor Court hearing the case noted that the employer did not ask the employee if they had an excuse for their absenteeism before terminating the employment contract. Based on this reasoning, it ruled in favor of the worker for severance and notice pay.
The court also evaluated some of the other claims, rejecting the requests for minimum living allowance, national and public holiday pay, and travel and meal allowances. Thus, the case was partially accepted.
The employer's lawyer appealed the decision. The Regional Court of Justice (BAM) rejected the appeal on its merits.
SUPREME COURT CLARIFICATION ON UNPAID LEAVE AND ABSENTEEISM
The 9th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals, which reviewed the file, highlighted the employer's authority regarding unpaid leave and absenteeism.
The ruling stated that an employee granted paid or unpaid leave by the employer cannot be expected to be at the workplace during the leave period, and therefore, absenteeism cannot be claimed during this time.
The ruling emphasized that determining when annual paid leave is to be used falls under the employer's right of management, and that an employee cannot take leave on their own decision.
It was reiterated that if an employee does not go to work by claiming they are using annual paid leave, this will be considered absenteeism in cases where the employer has not granted such leave.
EMPLOYER HAS NO OBLIGATION TO ASK FOR AN EXCUSE
The Supreme Court pointed out that in this specific case, the employee's absenteeism was proven by documents in the file. Ruling that the employer is not obligated to ask the employee for an excuse before terminating the employment contract due to absenteeism, the Chamber found the local court's assessment in this regard to be erroneous.
The High Court's ruling included the following statements:
"Severance and notice pay were awarded on the grounds that the employer terminated the employment contract without asking the worker whether they had an excuse for the absenteeism. However, the employer is not under an obligation to ask whether the worker has an excuse before terminating the employment contract based on the reason for absenteeism."
WORKER'S PETITION ALSO CONSIDERED IN THE RULING
The ruling also drew attention to the petition in which the plaintiff worker requested that the employment contract be terminated with severance. The Supreme Court assessed that this petition showed the employee did not have a valid excuse for their absenteeism.
The Chamber concluded that the employment contract was terminated by the employer for just cause, stating that the worker was not entitled to severance or notice pay.
LOCAL COURT'S DECISION UNANIMOUSLY OVERTURNED
The 9th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals found it unlawful to accept the claims for severance and notice pay when they should have been rejected.
For this reason, the Regional Court of Justice's decision to reject the appeal on its merits was overturned. The first-instance court's decision was unanimously reversed.
News Source: İHA