The prosecutor has presented their final opinion in the "expert witness case" against Halk TV. Journalists Barış Pehlivan, Suat Toktaş, Seda Selek, Hakan Kürşat Oğuz, and Serhan Asker are being tried in the Istanbul 54th Criminal Court of First Instance.
The prosecutor requested that Barış Pehlivan and Kürşat Oğuz be sentenced to 2 to 5 years in prison for the crime of "interception and recording of conversations between individuals." A separate penalty was also requested for the same two journalists regarding the charge related to the publication of the recording.
In the final opinion, it was requested that Pehlivan, Oğuz, Toktaş, Selek, and Asker be sentenced to 2 to 5 years in prison and a judicial fine of up to 4,000 days for the crime of "unlawfully disclosing data obtained by recording non-public conversations between individuals."
Accordingly, the prosecution has requested a total of 4 to 10 years in prison for Pehlivan and Oğuz for two separate crimes, and 2 to 5 years in prison for Toktaş, Selek, and Asker.
CASE WAS OPENED FOLLOWING THE BROADCAST OF A PHONE CALL
The case was opened after a phone conversation between expert witness S.B.—whose name was disclosed by Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu during a press conference titled "The Big Turnip" on January 27, 2025—and Barış Pehlivan was broadcast on Halk TV.
In the prosecutor's opinion, it was stated that after İmamoğlu's remarks, Pehlivan called S.B. to ask questions about the press conference and the files in which S.B. served as an expert witness. It was alleged that the call was put on speakerphone, recorded by Kürşat Oğuz, who was present, using a voice recording device, and that S.B.'s consent for the recording was not obtained.
The journalists did not attend the hearing, but their lawyers were present. Following the reading of the previous hearing minutes due to a change in judge, the prosecutor presented their opinion.
Suat Toktaş's lawyer, Serhat Çetin, stated that they did not agree with the opinion and argued that although the crime is subject to a complaint, the investigation was initiated ex officio. Çetin requested an acquittal, stating that his client only learned later that the recording was made without consent and that there was no intent to commit a crime.
Other lawyers also requested time to prepare their defense against the prosecutor's opinion. The court decided to grant time for the presentation of defense and evidence, and adjourned the hearing to February 10, 2027, at 10:00 AM.
News Source: 12punto