The 10th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals has overturned a local court's decision in a case where an individual sought to have their insurance start date backdated and to be granted a retirement pension, claiming they had worked at their father's business before the age of 18. The Chamber stated that an employment entry declaration alone should not be considered sufficient and requested that the actual work performed be investigated in detail.
The file was brought to the judiciary following an application made after the regulation for those affected by the retirement age (EYT) was enacted. The plaintiff requested that 68 days of 4/a service, reported under Law No. 506 between May 12, 1998, and July 25, 1998, be taken as the basis for the start of their insurance coverage. The Social Security Institution (SGK) argued that this period could not be directly accepted for the purpose of determining the start of insurance.
In its defense, the SGK claimed that the plaintiff did not meet the requirements of 60 years of age and 7,000 premium days. The institution also pointed to the legal conditions of that period regarding the recognition of minors working in businesses owned by their parents as insured; it stated that for minors with the capacity to discern, a written service contract with the participation of a legal representative and court approval were required.
ACTUAL WORK TO BE INVESTIGATED
The court of first instance had decided that the plaintiff was entitled to an old-age pension as of their application date of March 3, 2023, and that the pension should be paid starting from April 1, 2023. After the SGK's appeal was rejected, the file reached the Supreme Court of Appeals for review.
The Supreme Court emphasized that for insurance to be accepted, actual work must be proven in addition to a service contract. The ruling noted that while the employment entry declaration dated May 12, 1998, was submitted to the institution on June 11, 1998, and there was a report of 68 days of service, sufficient investigation had not been conducted because the workplace registration information and the relevant period payrolls were not in the file.
The Chamber requested that payroll witnesses and neutral witnesses be heard to clarify whether the plaintiff actually worked at the workplace during the specified period, and that the service records of these witnesses be obtained from the SGK. It was noted that if necessary, investigations should also be conducted through the SGK, police, tax offices, professional chambers, and local neighborhood headmen (muhtarlık).
The Supreme Court's decision also stated that, under Article 60/G of Law No. 506, the plaintiff's insurance start date should be accepted as August 11, 1999. Accordingly, it was assessed that the 25-year insurance period would be completed on August 11, 2024, and therefore the local court's decision to grant a retirement pension starting from April 1, 2023, was legally flawed.
Overturning the Regional Court of Justice's decision, the 10th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals unanimously reversed the judgment of the court of first instance. The decision has brought the importance of demonstrating actual work with concrete evidence for insurance entries made before the age of 18 back to the agenda.
News Source: 12punto