The case file in which director, screenwriter, and actor Yılmaz Güney was convicted following the 1974 incident that resulted in the death of Yumurtalık Judge Safa Mutlu has been taken to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) after nearly 50 years.
In the application filed on behalf of the Güney family by lawyer Bişar Abdi Alınak, it was argued that the right to a fair trial was violated during the proceedings at the time. The application also asserted that the incident should have been evaluated within the scope of self-defense.

CRITICAL CLAIMS IN THE APPLICATION
One of the prominent claims in the petition was based on a letter allegedly written by the murdered judge's wife, Nuran Mutlu, dated January 10, 1976. Lawyer Alınak argued that the statements in the letter show that Mutlu did not witness the incident and that her testimony did not reflect the truth.
The petition also drew attention to the positions at the time of the incident and autopsy findings. According to this, it was stated that because of the stairs and the height difference, Güney was at a higher position than Mutlu, yet the autopsy report determined that the bullet traveled from bottom to top. It was argued that this contradiction raises the possibility that the shooter could have been a third person.
A request for exhumation, which would mean opening Safa Mutlu's grave to conduct a definitive ballistic examination, was also made. In the process initiated by the Güney family in 2024 for a retrial, applications to the Ankara 1st High Criminal Court and subsequently the Constitutional Court had been rejected. Following the exhaustion of domestic legal remedies, the file reached the ECHR half a century after the 1976 conviction decision.
News Source: 12punto