Euro
Arrow
55,4123
Dollar
Arrow
50,5142
Sterling
Arrow
66,1149
Gold
Arrow
5709,2530
BIST 100
Arrow
11.131
Home > Sports News > Trio analysis on the controversial incident in the Beşiktaş-Gençlerbirliği match

Trio analysis on the controversial incident in the Beşiktaş-Gençlerbirliği match

Evaluating the controversial moments of the match where Beşiktaş defeated Gençlerbirliği 3-0, former referees reached a consensus that the Orkun Kökçü incident warranted a red card.

X Facebook WhatsApp Mail SUBSCRIBE Google News
Published: 09.11.2026 09:42 Updated: 09.11.2026 09:47
1 dk okuma
Trio analysis on the controversial incident in the Beşiktaş-Gençlerbirliği match

In the 11th week of the Trendyol Süper Lig, Beşiktaş defeated Gençlerbirliği 3-0 at Tüpraş Stadium, entering the international break with high morale. Following the match, the controversial refereeing decisions were analyzed on the "Trio" program broadcast by the rights holder.

A match image showing Beşiktaş players celebrating a goal.
Beşiktaş left the pitch with a 3-0 victory against Gençlerbirliği.

Former referees Bülent Yıldırım and Seçim Demirel focused particularly on the incident in the 49th minute where Orkun Kökçü went down. The fact that referee Atilla Karaoğlan stuck with his yellow card decision after a VAR review in the incident where Beşiktaş expected a penalty sparked debate.

Bülent Yıldırım stated that the VAR intervention was correct, but the referee's assessment was flawed. Yıldırım said, "VAR called for something else here. There is contact with the sole of Ousmane Diabate's boot. The reason for the VAR call was 'Evaluate the obvious goal-scoring opportunity here.' I think what misled the referee was the thought that another opposing player could reach the ball that came off Orkun. VAR intervened correctly, but the referee interpreted it wrongly. He should have shown a red card."

A match moment where Beşiktaş and Gençlerbirliği players gather around the referee.
The decisions of the match referee Atilla Karaoğlan were debated after the game.

Seçim Demirel also emphasized that the incident took place outside the penalty area. Demirel noted that the referee insisted on the yellow card, stating, "The referee insisted on the yellow card, but in my opinion, it should have been a red card."

Other critical decisions of the match were also discussed on the program. Bülent Yıldırım commented on Wilfred Ndidi's foul in the 2nd minute, saying, "Since there was no transfer of power and no stretching, the referee's on-field decision can be supported."

An image of the Beşiktaş technical staff following the match from the sidelines.
The Beşiktaş side entered the international break with high morale following the Gençlerbirliği victory.

Regarding the yellow cards shown to Metehan Baltacı in the 16th and 22nd minutes, Yıldırım and Demirel shared the same view. Both former referees expressed the opinion that both yellow card decisions were correct.


News Source: 12punto

Tags

Gençlerbirliği Orkun Kökçü Beşiktaş Seçim Demirel Bülent Yıldırım Süper Lig Trio Atilla Karaoğlan