Who wants to make concessions in Cyprus?
The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) was founded on November 15, 1983. The ANAP, led by Turgut Özal—a favorite figure of the September 12, 1980 coup, a high-ranking bureaucrat of the pre-80s era, a parliamentary candidate for Necmettin Erbakan’s National Salvation Party, and one of TÜSİAD’s favorite names—had won the November 6 elections and had just come to power. For this reason, there were those in Özal’s circle who found the declaration of the TRNC to be untimely and premature. They believed that the founding president of the TRNC, national hero Rauf Denktaş, had acted on his own, almost presenting it as a fait accompli without sufficient negotiation with the government.
There are still those who think this way today. In our country, certain circles—few in number but with a strong sphere of influence—always want concessions to be made regarding Cyprus. They say that Turkey cannot become an EU member without making concessions. Moreover, they want not only the demands of the EU to be met, but also the demands of Greece and the Greek Cypriots. These are the same circles that supported the Annan Plan, which was voted on in both sides of the island on the same day in 2004. The ruling party of that period also supported the plan with all its might.
THE IMPORTANCE OF CYPRUS
Let us emphasize that the Mediterranean, and specifically the island of Cyprus and its surroundings, is a place where not only the powers in this region but also the world's great powers compete. Cyprus is important in terms of the three major continents, the transport of Middle Eastern oil to world markets, and the energy wealth of the Mediterranean. Therefore, Cyprus is a national cause from which Turkey will not make concessions or take a step back, given its historical, political, social, security, strategic, and geopolitical importance. While England has two bases in the south of the island, expecting Turkey to give up on Cyprus can only be explained by betrayal, not by reason, logic, or foreign policy. To ignore the fact that the Greeks in the South destroyed the Republic of Cyprus, established in 1960 as a joint state, in order to turn it into a Greek state, is, to put it mildly, a lack of historical knowledge.
Let us recall that the Republic of Cyprus, established by the 1959–1960 London and Zurich Agreements, collapsed as a result of the Greek Cypriots on the island and Athens being unable to stomach this situation. At that time, an attempt was made to establish a balance between Ankara and Athens, as well as between the Turks and Greeks on the island. Turkey, Greece, and England became guarantor states on the island. To reinforce this situation and also to maintain the balance between Turkey and Greece, it was stipulated that the Republic of Cyprus could not be a member of an international or supranational organization of which both Turkey and Greece were not members. In that state, the Turkish side had the right of veto. In 1963, the Greeks effectively broke the joint republic of the two peoples. They began to massacre the Turks. We know what happened next…
UNDER WHAT CONDITIONS WAS THE TRNC FOUNDED?
In 1974, as one of the three guarantor states on the island, Turkey sent troops to the island to ensure the safety of the Turks in the north who were being subjected to the attacks and massacres of the Greeks. This step was both legitimate and in accordance with the treaties. Moreover, Turkey had been patient for a long time politically and diplomatically, and there was no other option. With this step by Turkey, peace came to the island and the Junta of Colonels in power in Greece fell from power. In other words, Ankara’s move also brought democracy to Athens.
When the TRNC was founded in 1983, it was known that the Turkish side would not be immediately recognized by the US and Europe. However, it was not known that there were so many lovers of Europe and the US within Turkey, and so many journalists, academics, bureaucrats, and politicians who looked at Cyprus not from Ankara or Anatolia, but from Brussels, London, and Paris. Indeed, in the time that has passed, the TRNC has not been recognized by any state other than Turkey. The pressures of the US and the EU undoubtedly played a role in this.
Moreover, starting from the 1990s, Turkey’s EU candidacy began to affect the negotiations conducted at the UN. The EU began membership negotiations with the Greek side in a way that was contrary to international law, its own rules, and the agreements between Turkey and Greece. Even though even the then-UN Secretary-General Perez de Cuellar said, “This decision by the EU is very wrong and will lead the dispute into a complete deadlock,” the EU’s intention was not to resolve the dispute on the island.
THE ADVANTAGE GAINED BY THE GREEKS THROUGH EU MEMBERSHIP
In the end, the Greeks in the south became EU members in 2004. Today, both the EU and the UN recognize the Greeks in the south as the representative of the entire island and as the Republic of Cyprus, as if there were only one state on the island and this state were the representative of the whole island. The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, which Turkey does not recognize as a state, met with Greece within the EU. This both strengthens their hand and makes Brussels a party against Ankara in favor of the Greek-Cypriot side. The EU wants Turkey to make concessions in Cyprus as one of the conditions for membership, just as it wants concessions regarding the problems experienced with Greece in the Aegean Sea, the status of the patriarchate, the seminary, and the so-called genocide allegations.
The Greek side is conducting negotiations not sincerely, but for tactical reasons. It does its best to gain time, not to appear as the intransigent party, and to create a perception that they are not avoiding a solution. Indeed, the Greek leader Clerides admitted years ago that they said no to what the Turkish side said yes to, and yes to what they said no to.
Greece is using this situation successfully in its own way. The EU voices Athens’ theses. While the EU signs the Customs Union agreement that unilaterally binds Turkey (1995) on one hand, it also sets conditions before Turkey in the voice of Greece regarding Cyprus and Aegean issues. Since the December 1999 EU summit where Turkey was granted candidacy status, the process has always worked in favor of Greece, including the periods when negotiations were frozen.
WHAT IS TURKEY’S MISTAKE?
In foreign policy and diplomacy, there is no need to kneel or make concessions to appear peaceful at the negotiating table. Turkey must insistently emphasize the following: There are two separate, two different, two independent, two equal, two sovereign states on the island of Cyprus. It is wrong to view the Turkish Cypriots as a minority community and to show the Greeks as the owners of the state and the sole representative of the island. Those whose minds and hearts have not undergone a national education may think of giving up Cyprus and getting rid of it.
Let us remember that the US and European countries, which did not recognize any diplomatic rules, customs, or courtesy, actively campaigned among the Turks so that the Annan Plan would be accepted in the north of the island. They interfered in the internal affairs of the TRNC. They took an open and arrogant stance against the founding president of the TRNC, Rauf Denktaş. In the end, the Greeks in the south of the island said no to the plan by 75 percent, and the Turks in the north said yes by 65 percent. Thus, the Annan Plan was rejected. The US and the EU made serious promises to win the hearts of the Turks in the north and to give them morale. For example, apart from the recognition of the TRNC, they promised many things, from lifting the embargo to economic aid, from sending an official representative to the north of the island to direct trade with the north of the island and sending tourists. So many years have passed. It is obvious how much they kept their promises...
On the other hand, it is unknown how persistent, willing, and consistent Turkey’s efforts are regarding the recognition of the TRNC. Especially when the relationship that the Turkic states in Central Asia have established with the Greek Cypriot Administration is taken into account, it is concretely and clearly seen how unsuccessful Turkey is in the recognition of the TRNC. EU representatives certainly know Turkey’s failure in this regard. Moreover, they tell Turkey, “If you want to be an EU member, you have to recognize Southern Cyprus, which is an EU member.”
Let us never forget that the moment Turkey recognizes the Greek Cypriot Administration as the sole and legitimate representative of the entire island and under the name of the Republic of Cyprus, in line with the EU’s wishes, the existence and legitimacy of the TRNC will effectively disappear. At that time, the Turkish military presence on the island will also be defined as “occupier,” as the EU wants. Because Turkey cannot keep Turkish soldiers on the territory of an EU member country that it officially recognizes.
Some in the corridors of the Foreign Ministry in Turkey, those who cannot call a Turk a Turk, those who have the blood of Ali Kemal flowing in their veins, used to call Rauf Denktaş “Mr. No” because they wanted to portray him as “intransigent,” “opposed to everything,” and “blocking the solution.” Time proved Denktaş right. Against those who do not see, cannot see, or do not want to see that Greece and the Greeks on the island want to own all of Cyprus immediately, and against those who say that it is possible for two peoples to live under the roof of a single state on the island, Denktaş’s following words are very famous: “Cypriot culture, Turkish Cypriot, Greek Cypriot, joint republic, these are all empty words. When they have Greece and we have Turkey, why should we live under the same republic roof? There is only one Cypriot living in Cyprus, and that is the Cyprus donkey.”