Euro
Arrow
55,5754
Dollar
Arrow
50,3822
Sterling
Arrow
66,5728
Gold
Arrow
6275,8513
BIST 100
Arrow
11.843
Home > Authors > Prof. Dr. Volkan Özdemir > Who lost, who won?

Who lost, who won?

X Facebook WhatsApp Mail SUBSCRIBE Google News
Published: 15.11.2026 06:00

The two-month tension between the Turkish and Azerbaijani administrations seems to have subsided for now. Note that I did not say the tension between Turkey and Azerbaijan; I specifically emphasized the situation of the governments. The reason for this is the necessity of distinguishing between ruling elites and their societies, as well as the rare and profound closeness between the two countries and their peoples! After this clarification, let us discuss whether the tension has ended permanently. To answer this, it is first useful to touch upon some information regarding Azerbaijan.

The recent crisis has unfortunately brought to light the extent of ignorance in Turkey regarding Azerbaijan. In addition to the weakness of regional studies, the role of an approach adorned with heroic and emotional rhetoric whenever Azerbaijan is mentioned is significant. Yet, the reality is quite different. First of all, it should not be forgotten that Azerbaijan has been governed by the Aliyev family for 33 years. Heydar Aliyev, who came to power in 1993, was a brilliant and experienced statesman who rose to the highest offices of the USSR and is the true architect of today's Azerbaijan. Indeed, thanks to the energy agreements he signed in the 1990s and the system he built by observing international power balances, the bloodshed in the country would first stop, then the economy would recover to some extent, and ultimately, the strengthened army would be able to liberate the lands under Armenian occupation during his son's era.

İlham Aliyev has been in power for 23 years, and although he has maintained the balance system inherited from his father, there have been changes in his trajectory. At the same time, he appointed his wife, a member of the Pashayev family who is a key actor in the country's economy and the training of cadres, as Vice President. Although economic inequality, nepotism, and political pressure have increased internally over time, he has followed a realistic line in foreign policy. When the Western-backed Pashinyan came to power in Armenia, it drew the ire of the Kremlin; Russia withdrew its support from its historical ally in the Caucasus, Armenia, and the path to victory opened for Azerbaijan, which was left alone with the Armenians. As a result of the 44-day Second Nagorno-Karabakh War in 2020, victory in the highly sensitive territorial issue went to Azerbaijan. Thus, justice was served.

The Baku administration has initiated a transformation process internally in recent years. The influence of some power centers from the past has been broken, and individuals, mostly educated in Western countries, have been brought into important positions, especially in the bureaucracy. In foreign policy, the balance established between Iran, Russia, and the US-UK-Israel axis has increasingly shifted in favor of the latter. As anyone familiar with the country can easily determine, Israel has tremendous influence in Azerbaijan today. Israel wanted to establish a system in Baku similar to the one it set up in Dubai, and it has made significant progress in this regard. The US and Israel had already been pursuing a strategy for decades to pressure their arch-enemy in the region, Iran, through Azerbaijan as well. In the war that took place this year, the situation began to take a very dangerous turn. The difference in stance between Baku and Ankara regarding a potential US-Israel attack on Iran did not go unnoticed.

On the other hand, while the motto of 'one nation, two states' was being promoted in public opinion, the essence of the relations the Aliyev administration built with Turkey over the years consisted of economic activities. A significant economic structure was formed with billions of dollars in direct foreign investment and increasing trade. With privatizations like Petkim and projects like TANAP—where Ankara preferred to transport its contracted gas through this pipeline at a very high tariff instead of its own BOTAŞ system—the Azerbaijani state oil company SOCAR reached a massive size in Turkey. Additionally, according to claims in the press, it is said that there is significant Azerbaijan-sourced wealth in the Turkish economy, ranging from marinas to hotels and even some funds. It is unknown how true this is, but one must also add the Turkey-sourced capital activities in Azerbaijan to all of this.

Despite these economic facts, when it came to bilateral relations, the average person was only interested in the cultural dimension of the issue. The liberation of Karabakh relieved us as much as it did our Azerbaijani brothers, and the joy of victory filled our hearts. Naturally, we always approached Azerbaijan emotionally and did not question what lay beyond. In other words, as we mortals focused on the brotherhood between the countries, it turns out the relations between the administrations had become quite 'emotional' as well. These comprehensive relations were almost never discussed in public opinion. That is, until the latest crisis broke out!

The face of the recent tension reflected in public opinion was the hijab ban in Azerbaijan. While mutual salvos were being fired via social media, the words of Chief Advisor to the President Oktay Saral were met with great reaction in Baku. Turkey was accused of interfering in internal affairs, and Saral's resignation was demanded. It was noted that Aliyev did not come to Ankara for the Organization of Turkic States Summit. While everyone was wondering what Erdoğan would do, he both dismissed Saral and hopped on a plane to head to Azerbaijan. These developments, which were a surprise to some, were actually quite expected if you approach the subject from a different perspective and look at past examples.

In my articles, I constantly emphasize political economy and state that politics and economics cannot be evaluated separately from each other. The recent tension between the Turkish and Azerbaijani administrations is no exception in this regard. There are significant economic interests at stake here. Most importantly, the current state of the Turkish economy is ringing alarm bells, and various foreign policy developments, including the Mecca Agreement, cannot be thought of separately from this negative situation. From this perspective, the reason for the tension between the two countries' administrations cannot be the hijab or talk of interference in internal affairs! Such excuses can only be functional to cover up larger issues.

If we were to take stock, the Azerbaijani side was right to say 'do not interfere in our internal affairs,' but it should not have interfered in Turkey's internal affairs, for example, during the 2023 elections. It should not have established ties only with ruling circles in Turkey and should not have taken a negative stance against opposition segments. Such examples can be multiplied, and the same criticisms can be leveled at the Turkish administration. For example, to criticize Azerbaijan's closeness to Israel, you must stand against Israel in essence, not just in words, or you should not enter into the debate of who took Karabakh. This victory is, of course, primarily Azerbaijan's, and it is not right to deny this. Likewise, no one should ignore the efforts of the Turkish army. Most importantly, the brotherhood between Turkey and Azerbaijan, independent of the governments, should not be targeted. That is, Erdoğans and Aliyevs come and go, but what remains are the bonds between the peoples.

The essence of the matter is that to grasp the real reason for the tension, one needs to focus on economic and geopolitical reasons. Although there is a pause for now, the root causes of the tension have not disappeared. Here, actors who want to change the map in the region within the framework of economic problems, crises, and projections like the Greater Middle East Project (BOP) should not be ignored. These issues should be handled much more broadly; there is much to be said, but let us leave it at that for now and add: The 'love' that has existed for years between the administrations of the two countries is surely not separate from the equation above, especially regarding the economy. As I emphasized, which political process can be thought of separately from the economy anyway? Time will show who will emerge profitable and who will emerge at a loss from the recent events, but in closing, I recommend you listen to a beautiful Azerbaijani folk song with the exquisite interpretation of Revane Emiraslanlı. Perhaps some of the lyrics in this song summarize the current situation well:

Who lost in this love, who won?

I do not know who will regret it!

Note: I respectfully commemorate our soldiers who were martyred in our plane that crashed in Georgia after taking off from Azerbaijan last year, following their participation in the victory celebrations held for Karabakh.

Author's Latest Articles All Articles