Searching for alternatives to neoliberalism: The London Consensus, Acemoğlu, and Mazzucato
The assumption that the contradictions within capitalism will increasingly intensify in the era of artificial intelligence is becoming widespread. We have previously discussed two different economic order options for resolving these contradictions or finding a way out. Is the redistribution of income sufficient, or should the ownership of the means of production and economic decision-making authority also change? Now, as we seek the answer to this question, let us look at the proposals developed by economists around the world against neoliberalism.
Criticism of neoliberalism among mainstream economists gained strength especially after the 2008 global financial crisis. The fact that states had to intervene in the economy on a large scale during the pandemic made the idea that the market is self-sufficient under all conditions even more controversial.
Today, the artificial intelligence revolution is adding a new dimension to this debate. In global economic thought, criticism of neoliberalism is increasing, and new searches are emerging.
One of these is the study titled The London Consensus: Economic Principles for the 21st Century, published by the London School of Economics. The book, edited by Tim Besley, Irene Bucelli, and Andrés Velasco, is based on the idea that the market-centered policy approach of the Washington Consensus cannot provide adequate answers to today's problems. The study emerged from discussions in 15 key policy areas and brought together the contributions of over 50 economists and policy experts.
It places issues such as the climate crisis, inequalities, technological transformation, economic resilience, quality employment, and state capacity at the center of economic policy.
In this approach, the state is not seen merely as an institution that corrects market failures. It is argued that the state should direct investments, support technological transformation, improve public services, and create conditions that will increase social welfare.
The conversion of productivity growth into social welfare, the creation of quality employment, the improvement of the education system, the fight against climate change, the reduction of income inequalities, and the strengthening of public institutions are among the primary priorities.
The London Consensus seeks an alternative to neoliberal economic policies; however, it does not propose a new social order that radically changes capitalist property relations. It seeks answers to the questions of how capitalism can be made fairer and how it can be extracted from the crises it frequently experiences.
The debate I am trying to bring to the agenda and the conclusion I want to reach are not limited only to the state intervening more in the market. In the age of artificial intelligence, it is a debate that centers on the definition of social-public ownership, and how the ownership of the means of production and economic decision-making authority will be regulated...
DARON ACEMOĞLU AND JOSHUA GANS: FOR WHOSE BENEFIT IS ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE?
The seven-question debate that Daron Acemoğlu and Joshua Gans held in October 2026 also makes an important contribution to this search. Acemoğlu argues that artificial intelligence is currently being developed primarily to replace human labor, which could reduce wages and labor's share of national income. He does not agree with the idea that new technology will automatically create new and sufficient numbers of jobs. He suggests that artificial intelligence should be designed in a way that enhances the skills of employees and creates new tasks; and that tax policies and rights over data should be regulated for this purpose.
According to Acemoğlu, the direction of a technology that will radically change the future of society should not be determined by the executives of a few large companies or experts. Democratic institutions and citizens should have a say. I certainly agree with Acemoğlu's proposal that the direction of technological development should be opened to democratic oversight. However, I believe that this oversight mechanism and the transfer of a share of the increased wealth to employees cannot function effectively without solving the problem of ownership. Because as long as the ownership of the means of production and investment decisions remain in the hands of a narrow capital group, it will be difficult for society to be decisive over the purposes for which technology is developed and how the created wealth is distributed.
Acemoğlu speaks of different crises if the expected high returns are realized, and different ones if they are not. This is an important observation... If the expected high returns of artificial intelligence investments are realized, capital's share of national income could increase significantly. Since capital income is already distributed much more unequally than wage income, wealth concentration could grow. If the expected returns are not realized, there is a possibility of a major investment crisis emerging.
Joshua Gans is more optimistic. He does not think that the returns on artificial intelligence investments will necessarily be taken from workers' income. He emphasizes that productivity growth can benefit both employees and consumers, and highlights the possibilities of new jobs and technological adaptation.
Acemoğlu's emphasis on democratic participation and technology that favors employees is important. However, the debate focuses on how artificial intelligence is developed and its consequences within the capitalist economy. There is no search for an alternative to capitalism in the debate.
THE ENTREPRENEURIAL STATE AND SOCIAL OWNERSHIP
Italian economist Mariana Mazzucato's books, "The Entrepreneurial State" and "The Value of Everything: Making and Taking in the Global Economy," deeply question the neoliberal economic understanding.
Mazzucato objects to the narrative that technological developments are solely the success of private entrepreneurs. She shows that the state takes risks in many areas, from basic scientific research to technological infrastructure, and that private companies also benefit from these public investments. Therefore, while the public bears the risk of investments, it should not accept that the economic returns arising from success remain only with private companies. Mechanisms should be established to ensure that the state and society receive a share of the value created.
Mazzucato's concept of the entrepreneurial state does not see the state merely as an institution that regulates markets. The state should be an actor that, together with the private sector, creates new technologies, production areas, and markets. She advocates for setting social goals in areas such as climate change, clean energy, and health, especially through mission-oriented economic policies.
Mazzucato's approach highlights the role of the public in creating economic value and the sharing of this value with society. She also discusses public ownership and the state's influence on economic decisions. However, the model I am looking for goes beyond this and addresses the social ownership of the means of production, the democratization of economic decision-making authority, and social control as a whole.
At this point, I must state that in the distinction between social ownership and public ownership that I discussed in previous essays, my thoughts on distribution and decision-making mechanisms were also inspired by the work of Prof. Dr. Bilsay Kuruç and Mariana Mazzucato.
These approaches reopen the debate on the role of the state and democratic institutions in the economy from different perspectives. However, the questions of who will hold economic decision-making authority and how ownership will be shared have not been fully answered.
These questions lead us to Thomas Piketty's proposals for "Participatory Socialism." In the next article, we will discuss Piketty's proposals regarding the redistribution of wealth, the participation of employees in company management, and the sharing of economic power.