The fund scandal, bribery in the Ottoman Empire, and social corruption
For a long time, our country has been talking about corruption, waste, extravagance, nepotism, cronyism, bribery, political party switching, and in recent weeks, especially the fund scandal. And it should be talking about them. Because all of these point not only to corruption in politics, the economy, and the bureaucracy, but also to corruption in society. The justified reaction of citizens is also shaking trust in political institutions. Both the government and the opposition are receiving their share of this loss of trust. Turkey is paying a heavy price. Looking at this picture, it is unfortunately clear that it will continue to pay for many more years.
At this point, we need to stop and think. Why is our country associated with corruption in politics and bureaucracy? Is this a fate? When we search our memory, whether it is the single-party era or coalition governments, right-wing or left-wing, central government or local administration, we see that major corruption has occurred in every period within the politician-bureaucrat-businessperson triangle.
THE FRIGHTENING DIMENSIONS OF BRIBERY IN THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE
Historical science traces the history of corruption in our homeland back to very ancient times. During the Ottoman Empire, corruption, bribery, extravagance, and favoritism were also at frightening dimensions. There is a great deal of work on this subject in academic literature. One of the first books that comes to mind is the book titled "Bribery in the Ottoman State" by our important historian, the late Prof. Dr. Ahmet Mumcu (İnkılap Kitabevi, Istanbul, 2005, first edition Ankara University Faculty of Law Publications, 1969). Ahmet Mumcu explained with documents that bribery played a very important role in the collapse of the state.
The Ottoman Empire fell into such a cycle of bribery that those who did not bribe the Janissary commander could not even get their houses painted. Positions and ranks in the bureaucracy were sold for money. One of the most famous bribery allegations is that Fatih Sultan Mehmet, after conquering Istanbul in 1453, had the powerful Grand Vizier of the period, Çandarlı Halil Pasha, executed on the grounds that he had taken bribes from Byzantium. According to the allegation, the pasha took bribes to lift the siege of the city. Undoubtedly, there were other reasons for the execution, because his family was very powerful within the state, and because he was in competition with Zağanos Pasha. He is the first grand vizier to be executed in the Ottoman Empire. Bribery became so widespread, common, and ordinary that in 1680, during the reign of Sultan Mehmed IV, the boza shops closed in Istanbul were reopened as a result of a large bribe given to Grand Vizier Merzifonlu Kara Mustafa Pasha.
In the Ottoman Empire, those who took bribes were called "çorbacı" (soup-maker). "Çorba parası" (soup money) was used in slang to mean a bribe. Until the reign of Mahmud II, civil servants did not receive salaries from the state. The state only paid salaries to the Janissaries. Judges would receive a fee determined by the state based on the value of the case. When salaries were introduced for civil servants during the reign of Sultan Mahmud II, bribery decreased, and heavy penalties were introduced for those who took bribes. When the economic situation of the state worsened and salaries were insufficient or unpaid, civil servants began to take bribes again. Those who governed the state, in order to put an end to this trend, enacted the Anti-Bribery Law during the Tanzimat period. The law did not work either.
KARAMAN'S CORRUPTION FATWA
What remains in our memory from Ahmet Mumcu's book also makes it easier to understand today. Stating that bribery is in the state tradition, Mumcu emphasizes that civil servants in the Ottoman Empire received money from the public under the name of "caize" (gift/allowance). We immediately recall the words of theology professor and politician Prof. Dr. Hayrettin Karaman, who said, "Corruption is not theft." We also remember Karaman for his words, "If it will harm the government, it is not permissible to tell the truth by complaining about injustices and wrongs."
Regarding bribery and corruption in the Ottoman Empire, the book titled "From Splendor to Extravagance and Then to Poverty" by our valuable professor, one of our country's most important historians, Prof. Dr. Salih Özbaran, describes the palace, administration, merit, bribery, and nepotism in the Ottoman Empire in the 16th and 17th centuries, as indicated in its subtitle (Tarihçi Kitabevi, Istanbul, January 2025).
On page 17 of his book, right at the beginning of the Introduction section, our professor Salih Özbaran reminds us that the splendor of the second half of the 16th century, which is referred to as the "golden age" of the Ottoman State, was described by one of the peak names of Turkish historiography, the teacher of teachers Prof. Dr. Halil İnalcık, as the "beginning of the period of chaos, the beginning of decline." While there are historians who define the 17th century as a period of chaos, turmoil, and transformation, he reminds us that one of the important historians, Prof. Dr. Suraiya Faroqhi, called the period between 1590 and 1699 "crises and change." Özbaran includes the following words of Sandys, an observer who came to Istanbul during the reign of Sultan Ahmed I: "Bribery had now become a part of corruption. It is of course impossible to think of a state mechanism where bribery is unknown. Bribery had gradually developed in the form of gifts."
In short, as the close link between political, economic, social, and legal developments shows, our society is experiencing both political corruption and moral corruption together.