Who are the modern-day extensions of Damat Ferit, Ali Kemal, and İştirakçi Hilmi?
There is a broad front in our country—from artists to politicians, documentary filmmakers to unionists, football club executives to academics, journalists to diplomats—that cannot bring itself to call a Turk a Turk.
The list is long. They are numerous.
They are against Atatürk and the Republic. That is why, if the Society of the Friends of England were to be established today—and there are many organizations that serve as its continuation—it would have no trouble finding members. Just as the Society for the Elevation of Islam or the Society for the Elevation of Kurdistan would have no trouble today.
They share common characteristics. First and foremost, they are collaborators with the British. They are enamored with the USA and the European Union. They lack self-confidence. They are subservient. Just as they do not trust themselves, they do not trust the lands where they were born and raised, nor the nation they belong to and emerged from.
They are open to receiving foreign funding and ready to take orders.
They are dishonorable.
The saying, "If they saw an occupying soldier, they would hug him and kiss his neck, calling him 'brother-in-law'," summarizes their character.
Although they represent the most pathetic, helpless, and characterless segments of Ottoman modernization, their influence in the palace, the sultanate, and the Sublime Porte (Bâb-ı Âli) is high.
Our great thinker Doğan Avcıoğlu summarizes the political climate of that period very well in his excellent article titled "Pabuççu Muştası" (The Cobbler's Last). This substantial article was published in the 58th issue of the magazine "Türkiye Yazıları," dated January 1982.
The magazine was a monthly publication issued by Ahmet Say. It was published between 1977 and 1983. The article can be accessed on the internet through open sources. In his article, Avcıoğlu drew attention to the influence of external dynamics during the Tanzimat, Islahat, and Constitutional eras, and interpreted the First Constitutional Era of 1876 as follows:
"The first constitutional experiment, which began with great hopes and was believed to save us from the interventions of European states, resulted in disaster in a very short time. A significant portion of Rumelia and some Anatolian provinces were lost. The right of European states to intervene was recognized in the most definitive way. Britain took Cyprus in return for its services in protecting us. A year or two later, it swallowed Egypt. France was not satisfied with Algeria; it also took possession of Tunisia. With the administration of the Public Debt (Düyun-u Umumiye), European creditors seized the main tax revenues. The Abdülhamit era began. In fact, Mithat Pasha and his friends were not against the Republic. However, they feared the people's loyalty to the Sultan. The public remained indifferent to the adoption of the constitution and the declaration of the Constitutional Monarchy. According to the American consul in Thessaloniki, Christians did not trust the constitution entirely, so they did not attach importance to the event. Muslims, on the other hand, were somewhat concerned about granting various rights to Christians. The words 'constitution' and 'parliament' were foreign to the people, in the words of Ahmet Mithat. The fact that the arrest and exile of the Grand Vizier Mithat Pasha, the architect of the constitution, shortly after its declaration did not spark a reaction is proof of this indifference."
As seen once again in Avcıoğlu's writing, the type of politician, bureaucrat, and intellectual who is alienated from their people, ashamed of their identity, and subservient to Westerners is widespread today as well.
Just as they did yesterday, they prefer to manage the situation today by leaning on a great power and making concessions to it. They do not think of going to the nation, trusting the nation, persuading the nation, or gaining the support of the nation. This situation is not just an indicator of ideological capitulation; it is a character flaw.
This is also one of the reasons for their opposition to Atatürk, the Kemalists, the Republic, and the Turkish Nation. This personality disorder of theirs is not a matter of politics, but of medicine; not for political scientists or historians, but for psychiatrists and neurologists.