Euro
Arrow
55,5592
Dollar
Arrow
50,3858
Sterling
Arrow
66,5558
Gold
Arrow
6292,1752
BIST 100
Arrow
11.843
Home > Authors > Meriç Köyatası > The contradictions of capitalism in the age of artificial intelligence

The contradictions of capitalism in the age of artificial intelligence

X Facebook WhatsApp Mail SUBSCRIBE Google News
Published: 08.11.2026 06:00

Artificial intelligence and robotic technologies are poised to change not only the mode of production of capitalism but also its relationships with human labor, property, and political power. We will either head toward digital fascism or build a strong, egalitarian, and democratic social state. In a later stage, we may even speak of a communist utopia where human labor is no longer necessary.

Utopias do not realize themselves. Democratic socialism will not fall from the sky either. To establish a new social order, one must first understand how the current system functions, what contradictions it harbors, and through which social struggles these contradictions can be overcome. Therefore, in the previous two parts of this essay series, we discussed the functioning of imperialism and how it might undergo change in the age of artificial intelligence. 

Capitalism and imperialism will not quietly exit the stage of history. It would also be naive to think that technological development will automatically create a fairer and freer world.

So, let us first look at the risks and threats ahead, and the contradictions capitalism has nurtured within itself. Then, let us discuss what choices these developments present to humanity and what kind of social order might be possible.

The title of the article we wrote on October 4th “What will come after neoliberalism” was. In that article, we stated that instead of naming the system to replace neoliberalism, it might be more appropriate to start by describing its fundamental characteristics. 

While defining these fundamental characteristics in the previous parts of this ongoing series, we discussed price and planning mechanisms in the data age, the social state and citizenship rights, the concepts of social property and public property rights, and definitions of the social state based on planned development. We focused on the control and oversight mechanisms of artificial intelligence and public administration. During the emergence phase of a new theory or ideology, we focused on the historical development of imperialism as a front of resistance and where imperialism might evolve in the age of artificial intelligence. 

The answer to what we will replace neoliberalism with is essentially shaped by evaluating these discussions as a whole. 

What will happen if the need for humans in imperialism and capitalism gradually decreases or even disappears? If artificial intelligence and robots create a production order where humans do not have to work, some basic assumptions of classical capitalism and socialism debates will need to be rethought.

A new order where the prosperity created by this technological development is used for the benefit of society, where democratic planning and market mechanisms work together, and where economic decisions are opened to social oversight. Utopia, or to use a provocative term, Utopian Communism, is perhaps a discussion for a much later stage...

But before reaching that stage, there is a much more urgent question we must answer: What kind of economic and social order will we put in place of neoliberalism?

My friend, retired Admiral Mustafa Özbey, sent the following message regarding the articles titled Utopia and Essays: 

 “Humanity is wallowing in the junkyard of things we have discarded without knowing what to replace them with. The 500-year Western hegemony is collapsing. But we do not know what to put in its place. Even if we take the easy way out by saying the 'caravan is straightened on the road' recipe will open an exit door with artificial intelligence this time, we do not know what troubles this artificial intelligence phenomenon will bring upon us... Life should have taught us this: 'No action without a theory can create benefit/value.'”

The institutions and rules of the international order established after World War II are being questioned. The inequalities, social unrest, and economic crises created by the neoliberal economic policies that have shaped the last forty years are growing. However, identifying the problems of the current order does not mean we know what kind of order will be established in its place.

It is perhaps necessary to develop a theory for a new economic and social order, and perhaps to create a new ideology based on this theory. For this, we need many essays, discussions, research, and critiques from social scientists, economists, engineers, biotechnology experts, geneticists, the medical world, the defense (arms) industry, scientists, and politicians from all over the world.

Utopia and Essays was the reason we started this series.

Moreover, the problem we are facing this time is not limited only to the failure of neoliberalism. Simultaneously, humanity is at the beginning of perhaps the greatest technological transformation since the Industrial Revolution. 

When we look at human history, major technological leaps lead to major changes in social structure, state organizations, the economy, human relations, and ideologies. 

After the industrial revolution, capitalism emerged in the economy, and socialism emerged as its alternative. Class structures changed. The industrial bourgeoisie emerged against the wealth of large landowners and nobles. The working class grew. New social relations were born between classes. Industry is a great movement of materials and people. This caused cities to grow. Along with cities, the organizational forms of states changed significantly. Republican regimes became dominant instead of monarchies. 

The critique of class relations created by capitalism gave rise to the ideas of socialism and communism. At the center of Marxist thought was the relationship between the ownership of the means of production and the labor that performs production. The exploitation of labor formed the basis not only for an economic theory but also for political ideologies aimed at changing the social order.

Today, we are facing a similar process. AI-supported robots have started producing in dark factories. Production organizations are changing. Instead of the concept of the working class that creates surplus value and is exploited, we are talking about people whose share in production is decreasing and who are beginning to be rendered dysfunctional. 

Historian Yuval Noah Harari, introduces the concept of “useless humanity”. One of the concepts put forward in artificial intelligence discussions is, the concept of “surplus humanity”... Both concepts very clearly reveal the threat that the working class and humans will become insignificant in the future.

Based on these concepts, I wonder how the capitalist system will treat people who are outside the production process, the “surplus population,” or “dysfunctional people” when the need for human labor decreases. I even go further and ask a provocative question: Will dysfunctional people be left to hunger, epidemic diseases, lack of access to health systems, in short, to death?

In the new social process that will come with this great change in technology, how will the relationship between labor and capital change in a structure where human labor in production decreases?

Of course, it is too early to say that technological development will completely eliminate the working class. However, in a world where robots perform production and artificial intelligence takes over a significant portion of the work humans do in fields such as design, management, accounting, law, medicine, and engineering, can we maintain all the assumptions of old theories without changing them?

On the horizon, it is seen that the sizes, organizational forms, and economic powers of classes will change. Then, won't a theory that bases social transformation solely on the revolutionary role of the classical factory worker be insufficient to explain the new conditions? 

The subject, form, and actors of class struggle are changing. The struggle for control and oversight over the ownership of the means of production and the concept of social property are becoming more important.

While discussing what we will replace neoliberalism with, we must think about and define these contradictions and which social forces, through which political institutions, will carry out what kind of struggle. 

A 20-YEAR PERIOD OF TURMOIL

Microsoft founder Bill Gates, in an interview published on October 22, 2026, predicts that artificial intelligence and robots could make human labor unnecessary in the production of many goods and services within the next 20 years or so. He speaks of an economy of abundance where robots build houses, farm, perform surgeries, and significantly reduce production costs. However, he states that the transition period until this abundance is reached could be one of the most turbulent periods in human history, creating winners and losers.

Bill Gates does not give a name or an exact duration, but he speaks of about 20 years of hell for humanity. 

Elon Musk predicts that artificial intelligence and robots could create such a great abundance of production in the future that they could meet human needs, and that working could cease to be a necessity. Elon Musk speaks of a utopia where people's needs will be met without having to work. 

I asked in the article titled 'What will happen if imperialism no longer needs humans?'. It is worth repeating. Capitalism is a system based on making a profit. Investors enter this business to earn a return on their investments.

Could Elon Musk's promises to humanity, or Bill Gates' message that 'grit your teeth for 20 years and it will get better,' be candy-coated lies that legitimize today's extraordinary concentration of capital and try to hide the inequality that is likely to increase even more in the future? 

Elon Musk and Bill Gates' prediction brings us back to the issue of property we discussed earlier. In a production order that does not need human labor, how will people get a share of the wealth created? Will this problem be solved without changing the ownership and control of the means of production?

The timing and scope of these predictions are debatable. However, their common point is clear: Artificial intelligence can significantly change the economic value and social position of human labor.

Two different future possibilities emerge here.

In the first, the increase in productivity provided by artificial intelligence shortens working hours, increases people's welfare, and facilitates access to education, health, housing, and other basic needs.

In the second, the same technology increases the wealth of those who control the means of production while weakening the income and economic security of broad segments of society.

TWO DIFFERENT ALTERNATIVES FOR AN EXIT

The same technological development can lead humanity and societies toward two different outcomes. The reason is clear: What is decisive is not only how much is produced, but who owns the means of production, for what purpose production is carried out, and how the created wealth is shared.

Let us recall a contradiction we focused on in the previous essay. In capitalist production, the worker is not only a producer. They are also a consumer. Here, an old contradiction of capitalism can become even sharper with the impact of new technology. In an economy where an increasingly smaller portion of people work in production, how will the purchasing power of broad segments of society be ensured?

Here, two different choices come to the fore for an egalitarian approach.

Let us imagine a model. The state should tax the wealth created by technology companies at a significant rate. It should provide a basic income to everyone. It should increase social state expenditures. 

Let us imagine a second model. The ownership, management, and oversight of the means of production should be reorganized. However, this should not be thought of as nationalization like in the old socialist systems. Based on the accumulated knowledge from history, social and public property rights should be taken as the basis. 

These are different economic order proposals. Both require a strong social state. In the first model, people can earn income but may remain outside of economic decisions. The second model requires changing property and power relations and establishing a very strong model of dynamic democracy. 

We will find the answer to the question of what we will replace neoliberalism with in these model choices. I must state that my preference is for the second one...

So, what is being discussed in the world in the search for a new economic order to replace neoliberalism? How do economists propose solutions to the problems of capitalism? In the next article, we will look at the searches ranging from the London Consensus to Daron Acemoğlu and Mariana Mazzucato. We will discuss where these approaches unite, where they diverge, and which questions they leave unanswered.

Author's Latest Articles All Articles