Peace Penal Judges are an automatic censorship device
In Afyonkarahisar, eight people, including two teachers, were killed in a series of attacks. Immediately afterward, a 'publication ban' announcement came from RTÜK:

'The relevant decision is of importance in terms of preventing news reports published in a manner that could create public outrage nationwide by distorting events and spreading misinformation through the press, as well as the gravity of the incident and the integrity of the investigation.'
In the work-related homicide at the Habaş Iron and Steel factory in Aliağa, İzmir, 19 workers also lost their lives; shortly thereafter, a publication ban from the Peace Penal Judgeship was announced again:
'..the justification for the decision is the prevention of disinformation and social outrage, the protection of public order, and the proper conduct of the investigation. A publication ban has been imposed on all kinds of news, interviews, and commentary regarding the incident until the investigation is completed.'
Peace penal judgeships have now put these decisions on autopilot. They impose publication bans without delay after every major incident. Fortunately, no media organization pays any attention to these decisions, which they base on irrational justifications as if there were going to be disinformation and social outrage.
Indeed, both the murder in Afyon and the accident in İzmir became news. Only a large portion of the media complied with the Ministry of Justice's request and did not include the incident of truck driver T. İ. setting himself on fire following the explosion in İzmir in their reports.
Publication bans, which are censorship-like decisions aimed at preventing the public from being informed, fuel disinformation contrary to what is claimed. The true antidote to disinformation is transparency.
One-sided news of a two-sided debate
One of the topics brought to the agenda by the opposition during the deliberations of the Ministry of Justice budget at the TBMM Planning and Budget Committee was the land registry records of Minister of Justice Akın Gürlek.
The first criticism regarding Gürlek's assets came from Yeni Party Rize Deputy Tahsin Ocaklı, who said, 'The court did not request all of the land registry records.' Akın Gürlek responded by saying, 'Look, I filed a compensation lawsuit against Özgür Özel and the court issued a partial acceptance decision of 750 thousand TL. The land registry records also came to the file, there are 4 land registry records, but you keep repeating the same thing over and over.'

However, this response was not enough to close the subject. Some opposition deputies interjected, saying, 'Passive records were not requested.' When it was his turn to speak, Yeni Party Istanbul Deputy Turan Taşkın Özer spoke at length, saying, 'Passive land registry records did not come to the court.'
Gürlek first said, 'All land registry records came, active ones, passive ones, I will not go into this subject again.' But then he brought up the IBB case and challenged Özer, saying, 'If you weren't a deputy, your house would have been searched' and 'Come on, let's lift it, let's lift the immunity regarding me as well.'
This debate was only covered in the Sabah and Türkiye newspapers on November 10 through the 'Let's lift both of our immunities' standoff. While Sabah continued the debate in the committee on November 11 with the news 'In the committee instead of the defendant's chair,' Akşam also joined the volley with the news 'Immunity challenge from Minister Gürlek.' There was no news on this subject in Hürriyet, but Gürlek's words were discussed in Abdülkadir Selvi's column, 'Could the immunity standoff extend to Özgür Özel?'
There was a significant deficiency in the news of Sabah and Akşam and in Selvi's column. Only Minister Gürlek's words were conveyed in the news, but there was nothing about what Özer said. Only in the news of the Türkiye newspaper was information provided with the sentence, 'Özer said that the difference between Gürlek's assets and his legal income should be explained,' and that side of the debate was not left incomplete. In the opposition media, as expected, Özer's words were not left out and were given in more detail in the news.
It is important that all elements of a news story are complete and leave no unanswered questions. However, news that only reflects Gürlek's words raises the questions in the reader's mind: 'Well, why did this debate arise? What did Özer say?' Of course, a journalist or media organization can have a side, but provided that they are objective toward the data...
He wrote a statement that didn't exist
Hayreddin Karaman, in his article titled 'Fund Conspiracy' in Yeni Şafak, said, 'Our Minister of Justice announced it in our newspaper,' and added:

'A conspiracy is being set up to finish off Erdoğan and his government, high-level audit officials are being taken over with bribes, the unregulated market is being dominated, and there is an attempt to collapse the economy by gathering billions in certain hands.'
I was surprised when I read Hayreddin Karaman's claim about such a statement by Akın Gürlek, wondering where he found it in the newspaper. Because I didn't remember such a statement. Like me, Karar columnists Taha Akyol, Akif Beki, and Mehmet Ocaktan were also surprised. All three writers wrote that 'despite all their searches, they could not find such a statement by Akın Gürlek.'
Hayreddin Karaman, a theology professor, is a name whose word is respected in AKP circles as well. We don't know where or how he read Gürlek's statement, but it is clear that he was mistaken. In such a situation, one would expect at least a correction and an apology, but he did not. He supposedly responded to the criticisms, but did not mention at all that he wrote a non-existent statement by Gürlek. He continued his articles as if the issue was not the 'fund conspiracy' but the 'Yazıcıoğlu assassination and conspiracy.'
Were the price hikes Fred Flintstone's problem?
From Cumhuriyet to Yeniçağ, dozens of accounts shared, 'A person in Adana wore a 'Fred Flintstone' costume to protest the hikes in fuel prices and ran in traffic with a car made of stone and wood.' There was also footage under these posts.
Many people, including Ece Üner and İbrahim Kahveci, reshared these posts, and then this event became news on many news sites with headlines like 'Creative protest against fuel hikes in Adana.'
However, some sites wrote that the person running on the streets of Adana in 'Fred Flintstone' clothes was social media phenomenon Erkan Toy (Erkan abi). I looked at Erkan Toy's social media account. He is a person who produces outlandish footage to attract attention, from breaking the floor of his house to enter the water he filled it with, to lying in front of the doors on the metro.
His footage taken with the 'Fred Flintstone' costume and wooden car is also for the purpose of being watched. Furthermore, there is neither a word nor a writing in those images indicating that he is protesting fuel hikes.
'Protest against fuel hikes' is also an addition made by journalists to attract attention. Those who wrote this news did not even ask Erkan Toy and get a single sentence from him. They sat down and wrote over the footage on social media. It's a pity, journalism should not fall this low.
Editors who kill the news
The news titled 'Don't have children, spend a fortune on cats and dogs' covered the front page of the Türkiye newspaper. The following sentences stood out in the spot of the news:
'Couples who do not have children under the pretext of financial situation and career spend tens of thousands of liras every month on their cats and dogs. While the sound of children in homes is decreasing, the number of animals is increasing. Those who say we don't have the money to raise children spend a fortune on animals without blinking an eye.'

I wondered how the information that married couples feed dogs instead of having children was reached, so I read the news on the back page. Alas, there was not a single sentence on this subject. In fact, the word 'child' didn't even appear in the news. The news, which conveyed the 'size of the pet products market,' included information such as the cost of animal care, food prices, and veterinary examination fees.
It seems that the editor who prepared the news for publication in the newspaper placed his personal judgments at the beginning of the news and published it that way. No editor can put their own commentary at the beginning of the news or carry expressions that are not in the news to the headline.
If an editor carries their own judgments to the beginning of the news instead of reflecting the content of the news, a result like the Türkiye newspaper's news emerges. We do not know how many of those who keep pets in Turkey do not have children, or how many of those who decide not to have children have taken cats or dogs into their homes; as far as I know, there is no data on this subject.
News reflects the truth and conveys information. Putting a baseless headline that does not coincide with its content and, moreover, distorts the truth, removes the news from being news. This is the editor's murder.
In a single sentence:
• İHA used the name and photo of the victim woman openly while coding the names of the two suspects in the news 'They beat the disabled young girl and made her apply for a loan.'
• In Sabah's news 'Cleaner entered surgery like a doctor,' there was no information that this claim was made by Zafer Party Giresun Provincial Chairman Mesut Aydın; the hospital's response to the accusation was also not obtained.
• At the 'I Met China News Awards' ceremony organized by the Chinese Embassy in Ankara, awards were given to those selected among Turkish journalists who made news after their trip to China.
• Akşam, Türkiye, Yeni Akit, and Yeni Şafak newspapers published the promotional text of the AKP-run Esenler Municipality as if it were news without putting an advertisement warning.
• On CNNTürk, Hakan Çelik devoted the entire hour-long program to the promotion of the municipal activities of AKP-run Kocaeli Metropolitan Mayor Tahir Büyükakın.
• Sözcü used Elips Haber's news 'Hikes are coming to cigarettes and alcohol' without citing the source; it corrected it upon warning, but the source remained as 'Sözcü' on many sites that took it from there.
• Akit TV presenter Erkan Tan expressed his discomfort with the commemoration of Atatürk by saying, 'November 10 was the scene of Kemalist rituals. Those who stopped in the fast-flowing traffic at 09:05 both locked the traffic and endangered the drivers behind them.'
FOR YOUR CRITICISMS, COMPLAINTS, AND SUGGESTIONS: [email protected]