Euro
Arrow
55,4123
Dollar
Arrow
50,5142
Sterling
Arrow
66,1149
Gold
Arrow
5709,2530
BIST 100
Arrow
11.131
Home > Authors > Meriç Köyatası > Freedom for wolves, death for sheep! Nobel laureate Stiglitz's alternative to neoliberal capitalism: Progressive Capitalism

Freedom for wolves, death for sheep! Nobel laureate Stiglitz's alternative to neoliberal capitalism: Progressive Capitalism

X Facebook WhatsApp Mail SUBSCRIBE Google News
Published: 22.11.2026 06:00
8 dk okuma

Last week, we discussed the search for alternatives to neoliberalism; we examined the London Consensus, Daron Acemoğlu's approach to artificial intelligence, and Mariana Mazzucato's concept of the “Entrepreneurial State.” At the end of the article, I mentioned that we would continue with Thomas Piketty's proposals for “Participatory Socialism.”

However, before moving on to Piketty, it would be incomplete if we did not mention Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz. Like Piketty, Stiglitz is a harsh critic of neoliberalism. Both question economic inequalities, the concentration of wealth in the hands of a narrow segment, and the influence of economic power over political authority.

But the solutions they propose are different. Stiglitz seeks a new economic order with the concept of “Progressive Capitalism,” while Piketty does so with “Participatory Socialism.” Let us first examine Stiglitz, and then Piketty. Then, let us return to the question we have been asking from the beginning: What shall we put in place of neoliberalism?

FREEDOM DOES NOT LEGITIMIZE EXPLOITATION

In his book The Road to Freedom, Joseph Stiglitz questions one of the most important claims of neoliberalism: its understanding of freedom.

Milton Friedman, one of the figures who laid the intellectual foundations of neoliberalism, established a strong relationship between economic freedom and political freedom in his book Capitalism and Freedom, published in 1962. According to Friedman, state intervention in the economy and the collection of taxes restricted individual freedoms. According to this understanding, the guarantee of individual freedom could be ensured by limiting state intervention in the economy.

The shrinking of the public's share in the economy, leaving the public's essential duties such as health and education to the market, the growth of the economic power of corporations, the weakening of unions, the decline in the bargaining power of employees, leaving markets unregulated in a world where perfect competition conditions have disappeared, the exploitation of labor income and consumers, the increase in income and wealth inequalities…

All these are a brief summary of the criticisms directed at neoliberalism by a wide segment of society.

Stiglitz uses the following expression in his book:

“The challenges and attacks on democracy and freedom have never been as dangerous in my lifetime as they are today. One of the critical failures (inequalities) of neoliberalism is that it expands the freedom of a small minority while narrowing the freedom of the vast majority.”

Stiglitz turns this approach into a slogan in later chapters: “Freedom for the wolves, death for the sheep.”

While responding to the view that taxes restrict freedom, Stiglitz questions the source of wealth. We can briefly summarize his thoughts here as follows:

• Today's libertarians, going even further than Friedman, have adopted the view that all taxes are an infringement on freedom. A comparison must be made between the narrowing of one person's freedom through taxation and the expansion of another's freedom through taxation.

• While one person's economic sphere of action is narrowed to some extent through taxation, the opportunities and freedoms of millions of people for education, health, housing, and a humane life can be expanded. What matters is how freedoms are distributed among all segments of society.

• We know what is happening today, but the formation of older wealth seems even more dire. In many places, wealth was obtained through the slave trade and products produced by slave labor, primarily cotton and sugar.

• The fact that the incomes of so many wealthy people are at least partially based on exploitation reinforces the need for us to prioritize the income distribution created by the market economy. Such income has no moral basis, but there is a moral argument that forms the basis for redistribution, that is, the seizure of income obtained through exploitation.

Stiglitz characterizes the libertarians' understanding of freedom as the liberty of corporations that hold economic power to exploit workers and consumers, pollute the environment, and eliminate others' freedom to live in a healthy environment.

PROGRESSIVE CAPITALISM AND DEMOCRACY

What does Stiglitz, who brings such solid criticisms to the inequalities caused by neoliberalism, propose? The author formulates the solution for a better society at the very beginning of the book and then tries to build this solution throughout the book. His proposal is as follows:

“In fact, the solution lies along the lines of a renewed European social democracy or a new American Progressive Capitalism, or a 21st-century version of social democracy or the Scandinavian welfare state.”

We can also briefly summarize his views on this subject as follows.

• I want to discuss an alternative framework that I call progressive capitalism or renewed social democracy, which puts the well-being of all citizens at the center and incorporates a sense of security and freedom that goes beyond material goods.

• Health, education, and a certain level of material prosperity and security are necessary but not sufficient conditions for this goal. Sometimes we forget, but the economy should serve society. The opposite is not true.

• A strong liberal education system based on Enlightenment values is important. A good liberal education helps us understand the forces that shape our destiny.

• The economic system needs to move away from centralization. There should be a wide variety of economic units, businesses, and different types of institutions that make decisions about what to do and how to do it. We must create a rich ecology of institutions.

• Free markets cannot be sustained without stronger democracies. The democracy part of the progressive capitalism/renewed social democracy vision is critically important, but to revitalize the democracy part, it is essential to revive the social justice dimension.

• To prevent the disproportionate weight of the wealthy, we can instill the idea of more strongly defending freedom of the press and a more diverse media environment.

• We are talking not only about one branch of government balancing another, but about the sectors known as private, public, and civil society keeping each other in check and monitoring each other, and a fourth estate monitoring them all.

• We must secure our democracy. In the past, there was concern about the majority not recognizing the rights of the minority. Today, in the US, there is concern about a minority not recognizing the rights of the majority. Voter intimidation, extreme partisan gerrymandering, and a series of antidemocratic moves by Republican extremists have endangered the country's democracy. There are strong reasons to worry about whether America's so-called capitalism and flawed democracy are sustainable.

What would Stiglitz, who directs these criticisms at American democracy, say if he had examined Turkey? I am very curious. Stiglitz also has a book recommendation on this subject: How Democracies Die by Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt.

Interestingly, the erosion of democratic institutions in Turkey is also examined with examples in this book recommended by Stiglitz. We should discuss this book in another article.

IS PROGRESSIVE CAPITALISM POSSIBLE?

While reading the book, I asked the following question: “Can capitalism be progressive? Isn't this an oxymoron?” The author also asked himself this question in his book and gave the following answer:

“Even if the system I briefly introduce here shares the term capitalism, it represents a significant break from the current system. The capital that is central to 21st-century progressive capitalism is not just physical and financial capital. It also includes human capital, intellectual capital, organizational capital, social capital, and natural capital, that is, it includes all the foundations of the economy. Even if we cannot succeed in creating an ideal society, we can reach a much better point that cannot be compared with the current state of capitalism.”

Although Stiglitz's proposals approach Europe's social democracy tradition, they are proposals suitable for the American left tradition, far from Europe's socialist tradition. Expanding the definition of capital is not the same as changing the ownership of capital and the distribution of economic power. Although progressive capitalism aims to control economic power and improve social rights, it preserves the basic structure of private capital ownership. In the age of artificial intelligence, it is important to discuss the ownership of capital and the distribution of economic power to prevent the concentration of power by digital companies.

FROM STIGLITZ TO PIKETTY

Stiglitz's book The Road to Freedom questions not only the economic failures of neoliberalism but also its effects on freedom and democracy. It shows that the concentration of economic power in a small minority limits the freedom of the majority. In return, he proposes stronger social rights, a fairer income distribution, democratic institutions, and progressive capitalism.

Thomas Piketty, on the other hand, takes the discussion to a more fundamental change in property relations. In Piketty's concept of “Participatory Socialism,” wealth must be redistributed through taxes, employees must have a say in company management, economic decision-making authority must be shared, and capital ownership must be spread to wider segments of society.

Stiglitz aims to make capitalism progressive, while Piketty aims to go beyond capitalism by democratizing property and economic power relations.

Next week, we will discuss Piketty's proposal for Participatory Socialism.

Then we will seek an answer to the question we have been discussing from the beginning: What shall we put in place of neoliberalism?

I do not think we can find the answer to this question only in models that seek solutions to the problems of developed capitalist countries. The needs of countries like Turkey, which have to strengthen their economic and technological independence, complete their industrialization, and sustain their development, are different.

For this reason, in the model I propose for the 21st century, I draw inspiration from Mustafa Kemal Atatürk's Republican Revolution, his understanding of economic independence, and his development policies.

Author's Latest Articles All Articles